Wherein I cling madly to my muse ...

Jul 23, 2011 19:51

Some of you may have read a story I started posting oh ... sometime last year I think it was. I think I finally broke through the writer's block and started posting it on SIYE - partly as an encouragement to myself to finish it. (Now I have to hope I can finish the blasted thing!) Anyway in Chapter 2 Harry is a perpetually unlucky in love bachelor ( Read more... )

fanfiction, harry potter, journal entry

Leave a comment

Comments 18

aggiebell90 July 23 2011, 12:12:20 UTC
What, do they think it's going to end up Harry/Luna??? I mean, you're posting it at an exclusively H/G site. It's not at all unrealistic that Harry (or Ginny) went out with someone else in the past. It's not at all unrealistic that Harry's lonely and misses having a girlfriend or that the girlfriend in question happened to be Luna.

I dunno. If they're that picky, then maybe you're better off with them not reading it, you know?

And I love that story, so you better not let them stop you.

(Icon for those people, not you, of course.)

Reply

aggiebell90 July 23 2011, 12:31:45 UTC
Yeah, so I just reread it, and those people need to pull their heads out. I didn't at all get that Harry was "in love with" or "pining after" Luna, just that she was better than, say, the screeching hag the poor boy brought as his date. Like you said, he's clearly arse over elbow for Ginny by the end of the second chapter.

Reply

kezzabear July 23 2011, 12:34:22 UTC
Exactly! in the face of the screeching hag who wouldn't compare favourably? :P

Reply

kezzabear July 23 2011, 12:33:41 UTC
I know right? It's on SIYE ... I think we all know how it ends ... *eyeroll*

I'll be honest, I'm struggling with the story - but I'm also wondering if I'm just a harsh critic of myself? People apparently adore things that I thought were pretty ordinary (and are full of spelling mistakes!) ...

Reply


sueatducksfoot July 23 2011, 15:50:27 UTC
We know Harry took Luna to the Christmas Party, it's not out of left field that they could have developed something more. I like the story and people are idiots. Ignore them and write it for us, they'll end up loving it too. And if they decided not to read it, then it's too bad for them. They are the ones missing out on a great story.

Reply

kezzabear July 24 2011, 04:44:16 UTC
I think one of the things I object to is the need to tell me "I really have a problem with this ship so ... I can't read your story, if only you'd left it out"

That's not a review of the *fic*!

Reply


luvmybaby101201 July 23 2011, 16:00:55 UTC
HUGS.

I remember this story! Love it - really miss your writing, and can't wait to read more.

PLEASE don't let the idiots get you down. Just...bat-bogey them and get back to work!

Sending *GO AWAY WRITER'S BLOCK!!!* vibes to you.

And some more HUGS,
Melissa

Reply

kezzabear July 24 2011, 04:44:43 UTC
The writer's block looms like a massive, ugly thing ...

Reply


nyladnam04 July 23 2011, 17:17:37 UTC
I was SO excited to see you posting this fic on SIYE! I was hoping it meant that you were working on it again (or, even better had already finished it). I agree with the other comments...the scene came across more like "If I were still with Luna I wouldn't have to put up with these hags and wounldn't be alone." He didn't come across as pining for Luna but wanting what being with someone he could get along with meant.

I think you did a brilliant job of creating an OC who was believable and made Luna look normal. And, yes, it is very obvious that Harry has got eyes for Ginny and isn't thinking about Luna. For goodness sakes, GINNY notices him noticing her!

I am bouncing up and down in anticipation of the next chapter...

Reply

kezzabear July 24 2011, 04:45:51 UTC
I haven't finished it, no ... but I am trying really, really hard! Posting it was supposed to have the opposite effect and MOTIVATE me not demotivate me!

Reply


jk_salmeier July 23 2011, 17:59:38 UTC
Don't listen to them Kezza. You're a great writer. The fic is hilarious and is clearly marked A/U. These people just need to calm down. Like you said, if its posted on SIYE its clear which two characters end up together.

Hang in there, please don't give up on it.

Reply

kezzabear July 24 2011, 04:52:31 UTC
I'm hanging in ... I'm hanging in ...

Reply


Leave a comment

Up