Temeraire-verse question

Apr 27, 2006 21:08


Small world-building question about the opening of Throne of Jade.

spoilers for the first two chapters of Throne of Jade )

books, temeraire-verse, sff

Leave a comment

Comments 12

batwrangler April 28 2006, 01:22:04 UTC
La, la, la, la, not looking at your entry to avoid spoilers, la, la.

You know she's on LJ, right? naominovik.

Reply

kate_nepveu April 28 2006, 01:26:26 UTC
Yeah, but it seems rude to say, "Hi, like your book, but this looks like an inconsistency . . . ?"

Reply

batwrangler April 28 2006, 01:31:13 UTC
Put that way, yes, it does seem a bit off. :)

She does take questions, though, and there was one other inconsistency that she handled with aplomb.

Reply

kate_nepveu April 28 2006, 01:57:20 UTC
Someone here might have a response for it; it might be a historical thing that I didn't know about.

Reply


marykaykare April 28 2006, 03:31:18 UTC
She mentions elsewhere in the book that both the aviators and the navy are under the admiralty. No explanation given; that's just how it is. Thank ghu I finished the book today; maybe I can get something done tomorrow.

MKK

Reply

cliosfolly April 28 2006, 10:36:56 UTC
I'm so glad you recalled that; I was thinking the same, but didn't feel confident that I wasn't somehow making it up in order to reconcile the discrepancy!

Reply

kate_nepveu April 28 2006, 10:39:13 UTC
Thanks--and now that I think about it, I think all the battles mentioned in book 1 were support for naval battles. I wonder if this parallels the development of air forces in our time, first engaging only over sea--out of concern for civilians?

Reply


Leave a comment

Up