Hello~

[hiimeka]

This is my first time posting here and I just got into the fandom and really love it.

I wanted to try and discuss a question I have about Chapter/Score 6 if I may~ Spoiler pictures of that chapter ...

Comments

[fabelyn]

Eleska isn't Nai. I think (because I've seen some raws but don't know japanese) that Nai's pain was caused because Karoku kissed the ring. Karoku doesn't seem to like Eleska very much does he?(look at the last panel)

Everyone you've seen in the ship is "Circus", the girl Nai bumped into a chapter or two before is also Circus. The guy rescued on the train who took an interest in Nai isn't.

[hiimeka]

Aah, I would love to see raws. And, ah, the ring? Okay. See, Karoku is definitely not nice is he, >:\. I don't think I'd like the girl either, seems annoying.

So Yogi, Hirato, and Tsukuomu are all in Circus?

[fabelyn]

Chapter 7 and 8 have been posted here and there are some pictures of other chapter in a Karneval topic in mangafox,. About Karoku, yeah, i don't like him either because (warning, spoilers ahead) I am about 99% certain that it's him that, in chapter 7, tries through a dream to convince Nai to stay away from Gareki. (which begs the question: how does he know gareki?!) (end of spoilers)

Yeah, those 3 are Circus

[hiimeka]

Herrmm ... poor Gareki's being booted out ...

[nanpa]

Haha I don't think I like Karoku much, either. He seems like he'll be a really interesting character as far as plot goes, but the second I saw him I got a Seimei (from Loveless) vibe and I've never been a big fan of those types of characters. After reading chapters seven and eight (well, as much as my Japanese skills could understand) he just seems too possessive and kind of creepy. :D; I don't want to spoil anything, though.

And I don't think Nai is Eleska. It's maybe a possibility, but I think she's a different character.

[hiimeka]

Um ... Finland icon. yes.

Haha yes! Very Seimei-esque, right? Except that I liked Seimei ... probably because I hated Soubi's hair.

[nanpa]

Except that I liked Seimei ... probably because I hated Soubi's hair.
XD That's possibly the best reason for liking Seimei that I've ever seen.

Also, as the person above mentioned, mangafox's forum for Karneval has a lot of spoilers from someone who's read through both full volumes. If you want to check that out, it's the last post on this page.

[hiimeka]

His hair was too long.

Thanks so much ♥.

[akupushi]

I just want to pop up and give my opinion about Karoku.
My point of view is totally blurred by the fact that I'm a huge yaoi fan ( everyone here seems to be, so yeah ) and I have only one explanation of his behavior so far. He's the hard to please seme who wants his uke for himself only and wants to keep him away from Gareki who's potential love rival. And the girl, Eleska or something, she's just a he dressed as a girl, lmao. And Karoku is so friendly with him/her because he wants to use him/her for something

But if, ugh, we leave that aside, I don't like his doings because I'm totally shipping GarekiNai ( Gareki is made of.. love ) and I'm praying something happens between them. And the blushing Gareki part. It's making me imagine really weird things that are probably not going to happen but whatever.

Not to mention that that because of the blushing part and the doctor's saying that they should discuss something about Nai's body I was hoping that Nai is actually a girl :< but a bunny? NO MAKE HIM A GIRL DAMN IT

[hiimeka]

I'm a huge yaoi fan"
so am i x>
hard to please seme who wants his uke for himself only and wants to keep him away from Gareki who's potential love rival.
agreeed, I saw this too. Possessive and sees gareki getting too close. [gareki's better with him, imo, cutier]

naaah i don't want him to be a girl!

[akupushi]

of course you don't want him too. no one does but since the chance of this manga turning ghay is low ( or maybe not but we can't be sure yet ) i prefer him turning out to be a girl because there's a chance of him and gareki being together, and that's very much the only reason i have :>

[fabelyn]

Sorry to intrude, I just want to point out that although karneval won't turn ghay, it'll still have lot's of hints of it till the end, because it's publishe in a magazine where most mangas are like that (it's the same magazine that publishes loveless actually) So yeah, there's hope ^^

Lol, everyone agrees karoku is just a jealous b****. And Gareki is so cute, he was so heartbrokenangry when nai pushed him away ^^ I don't think anyone wants to see karokunai

[hiimeka]

And all the main guy characters are just so ~pretty~, which usually has good signs, especially with Loveless-esque manga, eh

[fabelyn]

I agree, gareki and nai are the hotest and cutest manga characters I've seen in ages! And Yogi and glasses guy are pretty and karoku is very good looking nai sure knows how to pick XD