Revised Logline Critique Round - #18

Oct 07, 2011 16:18

Title: Unwritten ( Read more... )

critiques, writing, loglines

Leave a comment

Comments 8

kimberlyfdr October 9 2011, 01:23:25 UTC
I'm getting thrown information and getting lost. What childhood trauma? Where was the college professor in all of this? What was the focus of the smear campaign? Many questions, but not a lot of answers.

Reply


ext_319388 October 10 2011, 17:26:16 UTC
A few things:
1. I think you can streamline the description a little to just "pop star Katherine".
2. Your inciting incident is not leading to your goal. You need to word this like, "When Katherine's mother..., Katherine realizes she must GOAL." What you've written about her image being tarnished is already implied by the smear campaign.
3. I'm not sure how her goal "overcome the psychological effects of a childhood trauma" is going to result in her regaining the respect of her fans. Did she lose their respect because of the trauma? For example, if she was abused, you are saying they no longer respect her because she was abused but if she comes out and says she fine, she will be popular again.
4. How is her discovery connected to her goal? Does she have to choose between the two or is this relationship threatened by her journey? We really need to see more of the "If A, then B, but if C, then no A..." kind of thing here.

Holly

Reply


Leave a comment

Up