The New Class: Savages Amidst a Technology They Don't Understand

Nov 03, 2013 08:47

From Daniel Greenfield, "Government Is Magic," Sultan Knish, October 27th, 2013:

Our technocracy is detached from competence. It's not the technocracy of engineers, but of "thinkers" who read Malcolm Gladwell and Thomas Friedman and watch TED talks and savor the flavor of competence, without ever imbibing its substance.

...

The ObamaCare ( Read more... )

cultural, america, barack obama, political

Leave a comment

x_eleven November 3 2013, 20:27:45 UTC

It's often argued that the reason why the America of the early to mid 20th century could build "skyscrapers and fleets within a year ... and build them well," is because the products were simpler. It is true that the products were simpler. But it was also true that the tools we had to build them were also simpler. Today we have computers, design programs, word processors, spreadsheets, simulators and fabricators. The men of the last Civic-Heroic generation worked with slide rule, pen and paper, and tools wielded by hand. The difference is that they were focused on getting their jobs done, while we are focused on looking good while making the motions of doing them.

Great things were done with even less than that. St. Peter's Basilica was built with less. The slide rule had not yet been invented. Galileo had not yet published his works on what would later become known as Kinematics and the Strength of Materials ( ... )

Reply

jordan179 November 5 2013, 21:23:47 UTC
Eh, I disagree that all bronies are insane or sexually-twisted; I do agree that some would definitely scare Twilight, the more so since she seems more than a little prudish.

Reply

eric_hinkle November 6 2013, 02:38:17 UTC
I wasn't saying that, or at least I didn't intend to. I think it was meant more as 'fans can be very odd people'.

That and there is the general unlikelihood of Twilight being that much of a xenophile.

Reply

jordan179 November 6 2013, 20:11:47 UTC
Oh yes, fans can be very odd people. And some are less socially-skilled than was Twilight even at the start of the series.

Twilight is actually more likely to be a xenophile than are most of the Ponies (her foster brother is a dragon and she frequently interacts with other sapient non-ponies, plus she was humanoid for a few days), but I think she would be profoundly weirded out by some never-before-seen alien humanoid creature coming out of nowhere and professing to be in love with her. Who wouldn't be weirded out by that?

Reply

jordan179 November 5 2013, 21:37:26 UTC
Oh, one other thing -- Twilight is a genuinely scary person, despite her fundamental goodness. She is at least slightly obsessive-compulsive, has very high personal standards, and is prone to going flat-out crazy when she fails to achieve what she expects of herself or what she imagines Celestia or her friends expect of her. We've seen her have neurotic breakdowns at least twice on the show -- in the case of the geas she cast on that doll, she could have gotten a lot of people seriously hurt (she's lucky Big Mac's a nice guy).

Some of this obviously stems from the burden of bearing an Element -- you'll notice that all the Mane Six have gone a bit crazy or at least made highly-questionable decisions in one or another episode, and usually over something bearing directly on adherence to their Element. Some of it is her own strange personality. And all of this happens to someone who is potentially the most powerful and skilled mage in Equestria and now as an Alicorn is presumably a young GODDESS. Oh, and now has a potential sanity ( ... )

Reply

eric_hinkle November 6 2013, 02:43:34 UTC
If you were involved with Twilight, wouldn't you be a bit afraid of disappointing her in some way, shape or form?

Yes, I imagine it would be something to remember. One would have to be very careful with her, unless you wanted to send Twilight right off the shrieking deep end and turn her into Tyrant Sparkle (or whatever her name as a nightmare would be; Nightmare Eclipse?).

Of course that's assuming that you didn't hurt her and her friends and family found out. Twi isn't petty, and neither is Celestia, but some of her loved ones would take it VERY badly if someone really hurt her emotionally.

Reply

jordan179 November 6 2013, 06:25:27 UTC
I'm not sure of which her friends I'd be the most afraid in that circumstance. Most notably, one is a dragon and one has been known to casually break the laws of physics. And all of them are pretty much super-powered bad-asses under their cuteness.

Reply

jordan179 November 5 2013, 21:29:22 UTC
And I have to agree on the phoniness of Sunset Shimmer's display of remorse. I think I'd sooner trust the Joker's promise to stay honest.

Sunset's reasoning may have been -- "Ok, I'll pretend to be friendly with those five girls ..." (Twilight was returning to the Ponyverse) "... and then I'll shatter their friendship from the inside and take off some of them to be better minions than ever were Snips and Snails." Judging by how she behaved the moment she had the physical Element of Magic, she's at least as evil as (and possibly more power-mad than, having never had real power before) is Discord.

Reply

jordan179 November 5 2013, 22:26:33 UTC
... and of course, it wouldn't be hard to find better minions than Snips and Snails. They make Jesse and James look terrifyingly-competent by comparison!

Reply

eric_hinkle November 6 2013, 02:44:30 UTC
Agreed. They made me think of an evil version of Beavis and Butt-head.

Reply

jordan179 November 6 2013, 20:08:16 UTC
Their Ponyverse originals aren't even evil, just stupid (they really did think that if Trixie beat an Ursa Major the first time she could just casually beat it again; it didn't occur to them that (1) Trixie was lying, and (2) if she hadn't been lying then it might have been a near thing the first time). They were actually her fanboys and thought she'd appreciate what they did. When the corrupted version of Trixie returned, they did not grasp that it would have been better for them to stay out of her sight, which is why they wound up pulling her around on that giant sledge.

Reply

eric_hinkle November 7 2013, 02:00:58 UTC
Agreed on all points. I felt that a humanized 'bad girl' version of Gilda from first season or maybe human versions of the Diamond Dogs would have worked a lot better.

Reply

jordan179 November 7 2013, 07:10:07 UTC
Gilda was a cool "bad girl," while still being nasty -- I hope they bring her back some day :)

Reply

eric_hinkle November 7 2013, 16:19:52 UTC
I'd like to see her come back myself, especially if they don't make her lose her 'edge' and turn her all nicey-nice.

Reply

luagha November 6 2013, 21:34:27 UTC
You go to war with the minions you have, apparently. -:)

Reply

luagha November 6 2013, 04:10:45 UTC
My favorite comment on Equestria Girls was, "It's like Bratz, but without the misogyny."

Reply


Leave a comment

Up