Comments | jlrpuck_fic: Try, Try Again (1/1)

jlrpuck_fic

Try, Try Again (1/1)

Dec 10, 2009 05:12

Title: Try, Try Again (1/1)
Author: jlrpuck
Rating: M
Characters: Rose Tyler, Tenth Doctor
Disclaimer: Characters from Doctor Who are the property of BBC, and are used with the greatest of love and respect; no profit is intended from the writing or sharing of this story.
Summary: If at first you don't succeed... Rose looks for the Doctor as the ( Read more... )

support stacie, ten, rose

Comments 46

(The comment has been removed)

jlrpuck_fic December 11 2009, 17:03:43 UTC

Thanks so much for sharing and making me smile.

*hugs* You're welcome!

(The comment has been removed)

jlrpuck_fic December 11 2009, 17:09:49 UTC

I still feel guilty about how long P_C was made to wait--but I'm glad that folks seem to think it was worth it!

*hugs*

justlook3 December 10 2009, 13:39:41 UTC

Oh that was lovely! It should have been full of angst, but it wasn't because of the gorgeous ending.

jlrpuck_fic December 11 2009, 17:05:57 UTC

Thank you! I really wanted it to end on a hopeful note--because while it's sad that Ten never gets the chance to remember, the fact is that Rose does. As does James, in his own way.

cookie2697 December 10 2009, 13:40:00 UTC

That was lovely! I've been dying to see this prompt filled, and I'm glad it was you that wrote it, because it was absolutely wonderful :)

It was an interesting choice to have Ten never remember, and still choose to leave her behind, as in the episode, but to have Ten II remember later on. That's a good twist that I didn't see coming at all!

Thanks for writing :) This was fantastic!

jlrpuck_fic December 11 2009, 17:08:03 UTC

it was absolutely wonderful :)

Thank you.

That's a good twist that I didn't see coming at all!

I think it would have been terribly cruel to have Ten know what had happened--although I do think he's dreamt about it a time or two himself. But James...well, it seemed *right* that he'd have that dream, because of course it comes from any of the possibilities of what might have been. And I like to think he still has that knack, every now and again ;)

tripocket December 10 2009, 14:20:06 UTC

I think this hurts just a little..I mean with knowing what's to come. Beautifully written and believable, because I wonder perhaps if he did remember would things coming up been different? I think it's possible I'm still not prepared. Maybe I need a "Thing".

jlrpuck_fic December 11 2009, 17:11:29 UTC

I think this hurts just a little..

Oh, it still hurts me to read this. And I've read it a *lot*.

I wonder perhaps if he did remember would things coming up been different?

I've decided that Ten, like James, has dreamt of that encounter. But Ten sees it only as a possibility, not as 'fact'. Which of course hurts, too.

*hugs Ten*