Leave a comment

Comments 24

kurenai_tenka December 6 2006, 14:39:34 UTC
....you just rock. So much.

Reply

jjblue1 December 6 2006, 15:44:41 UTC
*blush*

Reply


akk_ December 6 2006, 14:58:55 UTC
This is really helpful.
However, the list would be even better if you included the sources the identification is based upon, so that a critical reader / writer has the chance to look it up and decide whether or not s/he agrees with your conclusions. :)

Reply

akk_ December 6 2006, 15:00:45 UTC
source as in "book and page number" (for example), or "anime episode at time".
Sorry, my previous post was unprecise.

Reply

jjblue1 December 6 2006, 16:35:39 UTC
Oh, you mean in the series... Mn... I could mention the volume or the episode number but not the page... (and I'd really like not to search for the minute... ^_^;) I can't mention the page because I've the Italian version of the CLAMP mangas and in them the page number it's not always the same as in the Japanese version...
Actually in the version of this list I've on my pc I've added/I'm adding pictures of the original place, maps (when I've found them) and descriptions...
I didn't feel like posting them here because... well they're taken as they are from other webs... and I don't know if I feel like adapting them. It's a lot of work and my English isn't that good, plus people, once provided with the name of the place they're searching, can easily find them just browsing in wikipedia.

Reply

akk_ December 6 2006, 17:09:49 UTC
The problem with Wikipedia is that the information there isn't as reliable as it seems, because everybody can edit it. You have no way to sort canon from fanon there, which is why original sources from the books, movies, etc. are so important.
There are a lot of interpretations abound, some valid, some plain nonsense - and everybody has to make up his / her mind regarding which ones are good (or at least usable / understandable) and which are not. :)
You have your own set of locations deciphered, but whether everybody agrees with it is another question. That's why I asked to give the source. It makes everything so much easier. :)

Reply


Wow! ocean_song2 December 6 2006, 17:28:04 UTC
What a patient gal! xDD SOrry I haven't had the time to post here lately, but I'm back to my very favorite hobby: annoy JJ to death! xDD
Ah, and 'bout that tarot card stuff: God, I'm Hinoto! @_@ Do I have psychotical and twin personality problems? xDD

Reply

Re: Wow! jjblue1 December 6 2006, 17:33:09 UTC
LOL but I like to be annoyed!
Hinoto? Scary....

Reply


sakanagi December 7 2006, 01:57:59 UTC
Wow, that's a really nice resource for the fandom. That could be useful for any detail-oriented fanfics.

By the way, I've added you to my friends list. I do read this journal often, so it's silly of me not to have added you earlier. ^^;

Reply

jjblue1 December 8 2006, 14:28:33 UTC
^________^
I'm glad you think so!

*blush*

Reply


kurenai_tenka December 8 2006, 01:10:03 UTC
I have no idea if you want me correcting your grammar here, but anyway XD

I was skimming and I noticed, (these three are only examples)

Kanto-chiho - Tokyo-to - Tokyo-shi - Chuo-ku - Ginza - Kimuraya:
"Kimura Store"
TB: Sakurazuka Seishiro bought here some Anpan. [TB Vol. 1]

Kanto-chiho - Tokyo-to - Tokyo-shi - Minato-ku - Akasaka - Top's:
TB: Sakurazuka Seishiro bought here the Top's chocolate cake for Subaru. [TB Vol. 3]

Kanto-chiho - Tokyo-to - Tokyo-shi - Minato-ku - Akasaka - Ark Hills:
X (movie): Kekkai. Destroyed by Sakurazuka Seishiro. Here took place the battle between him and Sumeragi Subaru. During it both died.

First one-Saku......bought some anpan here
Second- Saku.........bought Top's chocolate cake for Subaru here.
Third-The Battle between him and Sumeragi Subaru took place here.

Basically, you keep putting here in the wrong place ^_^

Reply

jjblue1 December 8 2006, 14:42:57 UTC
Thank you! I should have corrected them all now (I hope...)
Thanks a lot for the help!

Reply

kurenai_tenka December 10 2006, 16:19:39 UTC
Not a problem =D

Reply

jjblue1 December 10 2006, 16:41:23 UTC
You're sweet! ^_^

Reply


Leave a comment

Up