Smallville Fun & Games : Keep It! Lose It!

[jeannev]

 Well, I'm not sure how popular this will be, but I decided to go ahead with it anyway.  Because, what the hell, right?

Here's the challenge:

Of the 15 episodes that have aired this season, for each episode I want you to tell me your favorite scene (Keep It!), and which scene needed to be cut (Lose It!).

This can be as detailed, or undetailed, as you

Comments

[tasabian]

Also doing this from memory...

Lazarus
Keep: Clark/Jonathan scene at the end
Lose: all scenes with grown-up Lex-clone & Jor-El castigating Clark.

Shield
Keep: Clark unhappily cramming himself into Cat's pink car.
Lose: Scenes where Carter & Lois "out" their joint knowledge of Clark's secret (replace with scene where Lois delicately interrogates Carter to see what HE knows.)

Supergirl
Keep: Godfrey's first scene & Lois: "Goodbye Barbie Dream Desk!"
Lose: Everything else but especially Clark not being as "pure of heart" as Kara & Lois.

Homecoming
Keep: Almost everything with one big exception...
Lose: The scene where Brainiac 5 spoonfeeds Clark his future. Replace with vision of dystopian post-Darkseid future. Clark looks, says "Nope, not gonna happen, I'll make sure of it" then returns to dance with Lois, his freewill intact.

Isis
Keep: The secret-telling & flying post-it notes at the end & Clark's elegant rescue of Cat.
Lose: Every line of dialogue from the goddess Isis.

HarvestKeep: First scene with Tess & Alexander

[jeannev]

Thanks for your responses. Not surprised to see a lot of the same scenes pop up for us.

I agree....

[chatchien]

Lazarus:

Keep: Clark catching the Planet, and saving the people.

Re: I agree....

[jeannev]

Take your time. Like you said, we have weeks.

[canadabear]

I am using SVWiki to help me remember things, cause my mmemory sucks.

Lazarus
Keep: The Tess-wee!Alexander fireplace scene. But since that was part of a montage, I'll also keep the Clonex-Clark scene.
Lose: Chloe and the Fate helmet.

Shield
Keep: Pretty much all the Cat-Clark interaction, but mostly the scene where she tells him about her son.
Lose: The Carter/Lois kiss.

Supergirl
Keep: Godfrey torturing Lois. Yes, it was graphic and potentially unnecessary, but knowing the Darkseid comics as I do, it was also perfect.
Lose: Kara telling Clark that Jor-El trusts her now and has disowned Clark.

Homecoming
Keep: Future!Lois and her eye circles.
Lose: The Chloe/Torch crap. Okay, maybe just the Chloe crap.

Isis
Keep: I have no choice. Tess laughing her ass off at Cat. Followed closely by Tess annoying Oliver by finishing his sentences for him. And then the Blur reveal, which was 10000x better than the hugely pimped end of "Homecoming." And... huh. I'd keep a whole lot of stuff, actually.
Lose: Isis!Lois flying.

HarvestKeep:

[jeannev]

Cool! When this is done, I think it would be fun to see what scenes for each ep got the most thumbs up, and thumbs down. I think we're definitely going to see a pattern emerge.

[anonymous]

Hey Val! :D

[jeannev]

Thanks for playing Matt. You did great! Not surprising that you and I are really on the same page here.

[jeannev]

I'm trying to think of other things to keep us busy over the hiatus, because this is it. Ya know? After the show is over, who knows what happens?

But, we'll see.

Great list!