Elimination 5/6

Jul 21, 2010 13:19

Sadly we have to say goodbye to:


Read more... )

round 5: challenge 6, eliminations

Leave a comment

Comments 4

cartography July 21 2010, 12:42:20 UTC
I'd like to have my comments for #1 and #2, please. Thank you!

Reply


mercscilla July 21 2010, 17:04:55 UTC
Wow, thank you! :D

Reply


diek09 July 21 2010, 20:12:03 UTC
Congrats to the winner! :D

It's OK, I didn't even like my icons when voting, lol.

Can I ask you to plesa give my feedback here at this post, as I'm not receiving LJ notifications and I'd really like to have my feedback, unscreened is OK. Thank you, and sorry for bothering!

Reply

riekchen July 22 2010, 12:12:12 UTC
Okay, here is your feedback:

05 - cropping, flipping of pictures and composition make it look too crowded
05 - image looks blurry and you can see the line in the middle of the icon where it was cropped.
05 - The icon is too blurry and has a little too much contrast.
05 - too blurry

06 - picture is blurry and too pixelated
06 - textures are a little overbearing and John's face is a little washed out
06 - the image of John is blurry and I don't think the back of someone's head makes for an interesting icon.
06 - While I love the idea of this, the upper part is a bit too bright whereas the bottom part is too dark. The texture(s) also seem randomly placed.
06 - it's blurry and the coloring on johns face is too bright

Reply


Leave a comment

Up