Comments | je_ficgames: Prompt 2: You're Pretty Like A Woman

games_referee in je_ficgames

Prompt 2: You're Pretty Like A Woman - Team What-If

Aug 03, 2010 19:24

Title: To Care for Kizuna
Rating: PG
Pairing: Surprise!
Summary: The first episode of Shounen Club Ultra, hosted by Koyama Keiichiro, is being taped. The guests are Shuji to Akira, who are ready to talk about the last five years since they debuted. What if Shuji to Akira was not a temporary unit, but was acually the intended debut group?
Prompt: ( Read more... )

team: what if, round 2: prompt 02

Comments 4

still_ciircee August 4 2010, 19:18:04 UTC

I have next to no knowledge of KAT-TUN (a-aside from the fact that I like Koki) but even so, it was easy to see the points of divergence and it was interesting to see what would have happened, what could have happend. And though I know current events are not supposed to play into this I can't help but think of how this would carry though and that's really interesting, too. More, I like the way they explain things, the honesty as they talk about even the difficult things.

And, okay, I have to admit that Koyama pressing things and ignoring management really stole the show for me. I like it when the talent rebels against authority.

rolling_scone August 8 2010, 09:42:23 UTC

my brain flashed error messages at the beginning of this, because I was all 'shuji to akira, lalalalala- wait, what??' and then I had to go make myself a cuppa tea XDD

but a part of me quite likes this what-if (if simply because it's an akame fangirl's wet dream XD) because it is kind of unexpected and at the same time it makes bucketloads of sense. if it had been intended as a permanent duo they would have had to make a smarter match than kamepi (although, nwp is one of my favourite dramas, and I think they have a big part in that) and akame would have brought along the kat-tun fanbase. lol, shouldn't be theorising at this time in the morning. anyway! I really enjoyed the interactions of the boys, and koyama really gives off a pro vibe here. ;) you also 'filled it out' really well, the interview didn't seem forced even though there was a lot to it, and you also gave great background info.

omoikkiri August 10 2010, 18:23:48 UTC

OH my god, what. Akira was unexpected! But it makes so much sense!
I'm super curious about Yamapi's career now, since he doesn't have Nobuta or Kurosagi anymore. XD

I think you did an amazing job writing this, since it was ALL interview and therefore 90% dialogue, which must've made it difficult to build up tension and stuff like that. Loved it!

javiera August 30 2010, 03:22:48 UTC

This was an interesting take on things. I loved Koyama in it, for sure! But I couldn't get around picturing Jin as Akira... Jin taking over Yamapi's gigs in general kinda bugged me, but mostly Akira, considering Akira was more Pi's than he was the scriptwriter's, the character would have been WAY different had he been played by someone else, without the charm we all loved him for, probably.

I dig the idea of 3DK, though, completely!