Diagnose my computer: load-related shutdowns

Dec 05, 2010 17:06

So my laptop - 4+ year old 15" MacBook Pro - has taken to shutting down under high memory/high cpu conditions ( Read more... )

mac, tech-support

Leave a comment

Comments 16

dr_memory December 6 2010, 02:05:05 UTC
BTW, Apple's Genius Bar prices for service on old laptops are actually shockingly reasonable. They replaced the mobo and dvd drive on my old 12" Powerbook for (IIRC) $300 in 2008.

Reply


en_ki December 6 2010, 02:30:00 UTC
memtest sucks, compile Linux 10 times with "make -j"

Reply

jbsegal December 6 2010, 06:21:51 UTC
That page - from 2003 - links to http://www.memtest86.com/ which seems to have ceased development in '07. http://www.memtest.org/ is Memtest+ which is still being worked on. I'm going to assume they're getting better and better at what they do. :)

Now, I can't really speak to the current validity of the concept, but I really don't want to reset this system to build kernels on.

Thanks, though. :)

Reply


librarian December 6 2010, 04:21:20 UTC
Sounds thermal, you can try Cool Book to maybe underclock it

Reply


dcseain December 6 2010, 06:33:32 UTC
Sounds like overheating, as echoed above.

Reply


inahandbasket December 6 2010, 14:42:35 UTC
Grr, got logged out. That anon comment was me.
To repeat:
Memtest sucks, use Prime95.
http://mattgadient.com/2008/03/29/prime95-for-mac-os-x/
You can stress the CPU or the memory selectively, it'll let you figure out what's overheating.

That said, it's an old laptop so the thermal paste is probably toast. I'd be willing to bet money that tearing it down and re-pasting the CPU would fix it. That stuff has a limited useful life.

Reply

jbsegal December 6 2010, 16:29:21 UTC
What's fundamentally wrong with Memtest (or really, Memtest+, the still-under-development branch)?

And yeah, I've heard that about thermal paste, which is why I started with figuring out what the teardown looks like and THEN continued on to trying to avoid it. :/

Reply

inahandbasket December 6 2010, 16:52:02 UTC
I was a bit general in my statement, let me overhaul. ;)

Memtest, while great for error checking RAM, sucks for diagnosing overheating issues, as you can't separately test the various bits and pieces. Prime95 (or similar software) will let you zero in on which component exactly is overheating, from RAM to CPU to northbridge, etc.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up