Leave a comment

Comments 15

miscellanium April 28 2011, 22:11:24 UTC
i am going to leave you a better comment later because right now i can barely see through tears ;adkfjs

Reply

miscellanium April 28 2011, 23:31:38 UTC
Okay okay okay. This is not going to be very coherent.

The slow introduction of the facts is so well done, yet the beginning isn't so confusing I can't engage--it helps that you sketch out such a vivid scenario right from the start. I haven't read the book so I don't know how much you've used as inspiration, but the whole vessel thing? So so gorgeously creepy, and the fact that they all have Dean's eyes is such a nice touch--and oh my god the ending when we find out what happened to Dean, I had already started tearing up when Jimmy was walking along the road but when he walked into the house that's when I lost it because Cas and also Jimmy dsf;flaj the sense of loss is so powerfully conveyed throughout the whole fic--the way Jimmy's dependent on Cas (waiting for him, he keeps saying/having to say) but also not and I'm sorry I can't be more articulate but this is amazing.

I do kind of wish we had gotten more of a glimpse at what happened but it works really well the way you've set it up so maybe I'll just passively-aggressively ( ... )

Reply

janie_tangerine May 2 2011, 19:56:28 UTC
Ouuch sorry for the lateness answering - let's say I ended up having to write 20000 words in three days and I didn't manage to catch up with comments until now. /fail ( ... )

Reply


purple_pauline August 30 2011, 23:19:17 UTC
this was so good !!!! off to find more of your stuff

Reply

janie_tangerine September 1 2011, 22:11:36 UTC
Aw, thank you! :D Much glad you liked it. :)

Reply


Leave a comment

Up