Leave a comment

Comments 9

kith_koby October 2 2013, 14:05:37 UTC
Speaking of duels, have you seen this? livesandliesofwizards.tumblr.com/post/54568313148/the-wild-west-had-its-witches-as-well-and-today

Reply

inverarity October 2 2013, 14:24:03 UTC
Heh - that's cute.

Reply


ext_2080467 October 2 2013, 20:45:22 UTC
Speaking of raw power vs skill: how rapidly does an increase in skill allow one to tap into reserves of raw power? Alex seems to develop extremely quickly in Book 2 and Book 4. The former development is to be expected: she is practicing with her seniors and betters, so she's bound to learn faster. Alex's growth in Book 4 is more of a mystery: she acquires an ability to summon lightning bolts and can overpower several experienced duelers. How much of that is raw power, how much adrenaline and how much, dumb luck ( ... )

Reply

inverarity October 2 2013, 21:32:07 UTC
If Alexandra seemed to improve too quickly in book four, it's because I failed to show how much she had learned in that book and the preceding one.

Adrenalin does have something to do with it - we know from canon that even child wizards can perform impressive feats of magic when in danger (e.g., Harry Apparating onto a roof).

What exactly did Ms Shirtliffe do, did she block it? If so, then why was if briefly visible? Was it because it was not a proper spell, but a conjuration manifested by sheer force of Alex's raw talent?

Alexandra cast the spell, but Ms. Shirtliffe was able to counter it.

Reply

ext_2080467 October 2 2013, 21:35:37 UTC
Yes, she blocked it, but I wondered why it was briefly visible in air: normally, this does not happen. Was Ms Shirtliffe assessing Alex's potential by "visualizing" whatever Alex was trying to conjure?

Reply

inverarity October 2 2013, 21:52:58 UTC
You could think of it as the spell temporarily taking on a physical (visible) manifestation, before being dispelled. Ms. Shirtliffe stopped it before it actually struck her.

Reply


shinygobonkers October 3 2013, 08:43:39 UTC
Really like how you explained the dueling, makes a lot of sense to me, and quite enjoyed reading those scenes first time around.

Reply


lunacorva October 18 2013, 02:31:08 UTC
I think I've said this before, but I would REALLY love to read more on your theories of how dueling works.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up