Comments | inuyasha_lims: Round 25 Week 1 Voting

rhye in inuyasha_lims

Round 25 Week 1 Voting

Sep 03, 2010 23:37

Comments 13

rhye September 4 2010, 04:38:49 UTC

07 - The placement of the light texture on this image is very awkward. I like that Naraku's face was tilted-- it adds interest. But the viewer's attention is drawn to the light texture. The text seems added as an afterthought to fit the theme, and the font doesn't fit the word.

rashiea September 4 2010, 04:41:36 UTC

7 - Good font choice, however the light flare is very distracting from the overall icon & image. Either blurring or fading it a bit might help so it would more halo the character rather than seeming to go right over him.

surrel September 4 2010, 04:43:05 UTC

05 - I like how the use of a double image really helps to enhance the text. both text and use of images nicely match and go with one another.

rhye September 4 2010, 05:15:18 UTC

While positive feedback is allowed and certainly wonderful, you want to vote for your least favorite icon.

surrel September 4 2010, 05:22:37 UTC

Wow, I really fail. *a little tired from lack of sleep last night* That and I probably need to learn how to read ^^:

02 - Although the use of image portrays the theme very well, it's also a little hard to tell what the theme is without knowing it beforehand.

wockys September 4 2010, 05:28:51 UTC

7 - The light texture seems to take away from the dark theme

carnimirie September 4 2010, 07:03:15 UTC

Least favorite: 4
Reason: I really like the crop in this icon, but the colors are dulled, and the textures placed on top degrades the quality of the image. The text blends in too much, and the red lines beneath it are distracting.

Other comments:
2: I really like how this icon uses just the images to convey its meaning. Nice interpretation of the theme!
5: The colors in this one are nice and bright and the text is a nice touch. The insert of his eye beneath the text doesn't really add anything to the icon, though, but is more confusing than anything else.