Round 24 Week Three Voting

[rhye]

Comments

[rhye]

04 - This might have been a nice icon, but the way the white border cuts over Kagura's face in the top left really detracts especially from her eye. That is distracting and becomes the focus of the image.

----

Positive Feedback:
I love 02. The coloring of the background is excellent. The shadowed effect on Kagura gives the icon a very three-dimensional feel. The light textures in the background also give it depth.

[dechanter]

Least favorite: 04, I like a little too much is going on that it takes away from the image. I think it's cropped well but if it was without the border brush then it would seem more fitting, to me it's seem like that was an after thought.

Favorite: I love 03, the coloring is amazing and the worlds are perfect and elegant. And in 01 I like how defined the eye color is.

[chimesong]

My least favourite would have to be number 1. The crop is really interesting, but I think more could have been done with it. Maybe a little text - even tiny text - or a border, or something. The black space on the right and the way Kagura's face seems to lose color above her eye look sort of odd.

Other comments - I love the rounded edges and the font of icon 3, and the experimentation with different crops in 5. (:

[rashiea]

4 - The textures seem overly done and detract from the actual image itself. Good font choice, but less of the rest of the white overlaying Kagura would help make the image pop more.

[wockys]

4 - The border of this icon is rather annoying, and doesn't draw attention to the icon, just makes it look unfinished which is a shame because the text is well done