03 - The contrast in this image is very low. In addition, besides the sepia coloring, very little was done to the icon. The cap chosen is very busy for a base and without any other effects to add focus, there is no real focus on the icon.
2 - It is really difficult to tell what the icon is depicting. There is too much going on in the icon and the sepia scheme makes it more difficult to tell who is in the icon and what they're doing.
1 - It doesn't appear as sepia-toned overall and the white border makes a rather jagged cut-out of the central image. The tinytext looks like it should be readable the way that it's placed, but isn't, which makes it seem awkward as well. Perhaps removing the border or smoothing it out and moving the text would help.
3 - I think is a nice crop but the icon would look better without the yellow tinted texture and the dots at the bottom that make the picture lose its details.
02 - I can't really see what's going on in this icon. It's too flat to be able to make out the characters right away. Perhaps using a different method of making the image sepia would have helped.
Other Comments
03 - I really like the effect of this icon. My eyes are immediatly pulled to it! The touch of yellow-ish is really cool, and gives the icon an old stamp feel.
Comments 9
Reply
2 - It is really difficult to tell what the icon is depicting. There is too much going on in the icon and the sepia scheme makes it more difficult to tell who is in the icon and what they're doing.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Other Comments
03 - I really like the effect of this icon. My eyes are immediatly pulled to it! The touch of yellow-ish is really cool, and gives the icon an old stamp feel.
Reply
Leave a comment