Comments | inulovinkit: Suzaku of the Counterattack Review

inulovinkit

Suzaku of the Counterattack Review

Jan 10, 2009 01:48

D<

Okay, so...they took what would have made an awesome idea and...killed it. Just killed it.

The art is alright, the premise is all right, but the presence of that FUCKING SO OBVIOUS MARY SUE just DESTROYS IT.

Okay, so, you get rid of Cecile for a cute girl. Okay, sure. Then the girl is just only one year older than Suzaku. Allllrighty.

She somehow ( Read more... )

rage, code geass, suzaku of the counterattack, suzaku

Comments 13

lavaliere January 10 2009, 07:29:54 UTC

Nightmare of Nunnally >>>>>>>>> ALL OTHERS

:] I almost want to say it's better than the original. It's close... very close.

miraido January 10 2009, 21:34:35 UTC

It so does. Though I think what caught most people off guard on Nightmare of nunally was Buff Zero with his CLOAK OF BLACK FIRE.

tenshi789 January 10 2009, 23:17:27 UTC

awww really I thought Suzaku of the Counterattack was the good one D:

inulovinkit January 11 2009, 09:09:14 UTC

Well, the art is cool, the new take on the story is awesome, so if you can ignore the Mary Sue (I can't. D<) then its good, I guess.

tenshi789 January 11 2009, 11:23:54 UTC

Yeah, I was reading some of it before and I was just like wtf

-_-

You wrote "He angsts over this until the end of the book." Does that mean she dies? Or is that just her father or something.

inulovinkit January 12 2009, 07:40:31 UTC

No, just her dad dies, unfortunately. >(

Thread 5

realms_of_life January 10 2009, 23:49:43 UTC

You know, the best thing about Counterattack is the GAY ending. It's so gay it is actually hilarious, especially considering this was supposed to be the HET version. *XD Good times.

inulovinkit January 11 2009, 09:10:05 UTC

Is the one where Suza sticks the gun in Lulu's mouth in the cave gunfight showdown? Or was that the regular manga?

realms_of_life January 11 2009, 09:55:30 UTC

I can't remember. *XD The gay ending deleted all previous information from my brain. Also, your icon is awesome. Do you know who is the artist?

inulovinkit January 12 2009, 07:41:45 UTC

Nope, it was just an image I found on aarinfantasy yaoi gallery and yoinked for a new Suzalulu icon.

phantasiagirl January 13 2009, 14:41:28 UTC

I KNEW I WASN'T THE ONLY ONE. D:

Though the art is very pretty. ♥ Oh, and you forgot one, Lloyd is like uber-friendly towards her. It might not mean much because he's...Lloyd, but it gave me vibes.

I can't wait until Nightmare of Nunnally comes out. And I'm curious of this GAY ending other people are speaking of...

confused yaoienjoy20 January 31 2009, 02:40:44 UTC

wat?=\