ROUND #1 CHALLENGE #2 RESULTS

[arbuus]

sadly, we have to say goodbye to one more person this challenge! (hopefully she'll stick around to vote and will participate in round 2)

Comments

[anonymous]

[anonymous]

[whitestroke]

Uhmmm. I'm not so sure am I allowed to speak up about this. That's why I suggested those criticism posts to you, where we could all discuss and say our opinions on other people's comments... So delete this if you think it's not my place to say this.

The image feels squashed together and the border feels a little too bright for the rest of the image.
I'm like... what?! o__O (For the record, I neither voted off nor voted for this icon, so I can speak objectively.) Maybe it's just me, but I think that was the whole point of this icon. They're not SQUASHED. She just put them together, closer to each other so they can fit the circle and it actually turned out really professional. Does a person who commented this has any idea how hard was (technically) to do this? They're not distorted or anything. I believe she cropped each and one of them separately and put them together.That's one hell of a job.

*cough* Sorry. Like I said. Delete this if you wish...

[arbuus]

no that's ok, (i forgot to screen it, because my computer was acting up and i had to restart it), but i agree, i was going to pick it as mod's choice, because i liked the way she solved the problem of the guys being so far apart, that it was hard to include them all on the icon and make it look nice.

[whitestroke]

LOL I didn't get any votes this time. Neither positive nor negative.
Sorry. I just had to spazz in here. Hahahaha!!!

My friend loserpunkchick4 told me the other day that her icon was the one that got no votes last week. (#9, I think. Of Arctic Monkeys. Not THIS challenge. LOL) And she thought it's not a very good sign. People neither liked it nor hated it. As if they were indifferent towards it. But I told her I think that was pretty cool. We have to vote off 3 icons, man, and no one found anything wrong about it. That's awesome. Haha. I guess my dream came true this week. And remember how unsure I was about submitting it?! I thought it was the worst icon I ever made. LOL

Oh man. I'm long again. It seems like I love talking to you or something... :)

[arbuus]

haha, well actually my icon was the other one that didn't get any voes this time =)
and i never know what to feel when that happens, am i supposed to be happy that no one found anything wrong with my icon or should i be sad, because no one liked my icon?
but i guess it's up to everyone to decide how to take it.
i'd just mostly like to get feedback, good or bad, doesn't matter =)

haha, i've noticed, and the comments keep getting longer =)

[whitestroke]

haha, well actually my icon was the other one that didn't get any votes this time.
For real!? We're like Challenge #2 twins. xD

I'll tell you the same thing I told her.
I think that's a very good thing. Because positive votes don't matter that much when you think about it. You can vote for only ONE icon, and as you said, almost everyone votes for something else. People's Choice usually ends up being the icon with like 2 votes or something. And everyone needs to vote off THREE icons. And no one found anything wrong about our icons. And it was only like 11 of them, right?! I'd say you and me scored this week. Even the icon that won People's Choice got one negative vote, but we didn't. ;P

and the comments keep getting longer.
I know. What's that all about? You should start spanking me. (Begging me to stop never works. :P)

[arbuus]

LOL, yeah =)

yeah, well, when you look at it from that angle, it's not so bad =)

lol, that sounds kinky!!!!

(wow, a short comment for a change!)

[arbuus]

OH.MY.GOD. i think i love you now!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
thankyouthankyouthankyouthankyouthankyou!!!

anyway, are you sure you don't want your comments?