O.O okay... lets sum up... i work on an icon and like it, and i get lots of negative votes... i make an icon in ten minutes, while drunk off my ass, and people like it? this is just weird...
also sorry for not voting myself this week 8was abit preoccupied... what with my hangover aso)
and: i think it's a bit harsh to use "the icon is just boring" or sth. of the kind in a comment... this is supposed to be somehow constructive... and i didn't say anything in the past weeks... but now... how is it constructive so say "it's boring" or even "it's simple" - simple can be good!!! some people don't like it, and that's okay... but just saying an icon is simple isn't criticism it's a statement... and it does at least state in the rules to vote according to quality and not to personal preference...
well.. about the last part- i guess as long as the comment doesn't say 'i think it's..' or 'i don't like the..' or 'in my opinion..' or something like that, then it's not really personal opinion. and i guess 'boring' or 'simple' aren't the best ('dull' works however) and i think people should elaborate or say what they mean by 'boring' or 'simple' and give suggestions or something..
i know, and it wasn't meant for you (hey, you're doing a great job*hugz*), but for the people who write things like that... didn't wanna diss anyone for that matter... it just annoys me a bit
and i think if they elaborated a bit it would work... but just saying the icon is too simple - it just doesn't really mean anything... they didn't say, why that is so bad... and boring sounds an awful lot like personal opinion to me...
Comments 5
also sorry for not voting myself this week 8was abit preoccupied... what with my hangover aso)
and: i think it's a bit harsh to use "the icon is just boring" or sth. of the kind in a comment... this is supposed to be somehow constructive... and i didn't say anything in the past weeks... but now... how is it constructive so say "it's boring" or even "it's simple" - simple can be good!!! some people don't like it, and that's okay... but just saying an icon is simple isn't criticism it's a statement... and it does at least state in the rules to vote according to quality and not to personal preference...
Reply
Reply
and i think if they elaborated a bit it would work... but just saying the icon is too simple - it just doesn't really mean anything... they didn't say, why that is so bad... and boring sounds an awful lot like personal opinion to me...
Reply
It was good fun while it lasted =)!
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment