Leave a comment

Comments 9

eponis May 2 2011, 03:04:21 UTC
I think that with that one, it's because it's just so OMG-WHAT that I didn't even know where to start. And the comment about how she was dreaming??

All I can say is that if they actually do do something like "this whole season was a dream," I will seriously kill someone. But I truly have no idea what else it could mean.

Still creeped out by these episodes. I just hope that they're not the norm, because hide-behind-the-couch moments was never why I watched Who.

Reply

idlerat May 2 2011, 03:27:24 UTC
Yes, Ellen said exactly the same thing - about not knowing where to begin. I am sure it won't be something as simple as "it was all a dream," but I also think there is some serious mucking with perceptions here, even beyond what has already been established with the Silence. For instance, I think there might be a power behind the Silence. Or something. I don't know. We do know that whatever was happening with Amy in this sequence was already seriously WTF, with the picture of her with the baby, and the child - her child? but she's just pregnant now? - busting out of the suit just when Amy is getting abducted, and the way she just *had to tell the Doctor she was pregnant right then* before she shot the space suit last time ( ... )

Reply

eponis May 2 2011, 03:37:06 UTC
Oh, don't get me wrong, I love Moffatt and Eleven. I just easily get creeped out, and the Silence managed to push my buttons very effectively ( ... )

Reply

idlerat May 2 2011, 23:54:22 UTC
Hah, I said on FB that they were a cross between the Gentlemen ("Hush") and the Dementors.

I think there may be a couple things still hanging out from last season. We just rewatched Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead (hdgf likes River YAY!), and it was so tightly consistent with everything that has come after. Very cool, IMO>

Reply


stormwynd May 2 2011, 15:54:34 UTC
I agree with PP's that we may be looking at some timey wimey stuff here. Who's the girl in the space suit? Who's the woman with the awesome/creepy metal eyepatch thingy in the door? What the heck is Badger doing in the Whoverse? Well, maybe not that last one.

I'm not a big fan of the horror/suspense creepiness, but that's my own taste rather than a general statement about the quality of 6.01 and 6.02. I think they were pretty good, even though (or perhaps because?) they left some pretty interesting questions unanswered.

Reply

idlerat May 2 2011, 23:51:18 UTC
Hey Dave, long time no see! Yeah there is definitely wibbly wobbly timey wimey stuff here. Very much looking forward to a season-long (or maybe longer - there seems to be be some stuff from last year lying about) unraveling.

Reply

stormwynd May 3 2011, 01:47:15 UTC
It seems to me that seasons 5 and 6 are tending more towards season-long story arcs than seasons 1 - 4 did -- I wonder if the change in showrunner has anything to do with it.

But yeah, I'm looking forwards to seeing how all the threads unravel.

Reply


mcamy May 2 2011, 22:17:36 UTC
This reminded me of Girl in the Fireplace, actually--like somebody was looking into Amy's timeline and checking up on her. Don't know what it will actually turn out to be!

Reply

idlerat May 2 2011, 23:48:56 UTC
Mm, yeah. I was thinking along the lines of a power behind the Silence, but I like this - I should watch Girl in the Fireplace again.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up