Soul Punk review in Rolling Stone

[icecreamhdaches]

Comments

[nametags]

Three and a half? Is that out of 4 or 5?

[rockee23]

I think rolling stone does 4 stars but I'm not positive.

[agent99]

i think it's 5 but honestly 5 only goes to like "John Lennon's Greatest Hits Remastered" or something, and they don't give 4s out very freely. Three and a half is pretty good for them.

[headinaflurry]

In the magazines, I'm FAIRLY sure it's out of 4.

Online, it's out of 5... and Soul Punk has 4.5 out of 5.

But I'm completely confused as to why the website and magazine for the same source would have different rating systems. Eh. Good ratings, either way! :p

[dwn_in_brktown]

How are they going to recommend a song thats only available on the delux copy of SP. Oh silly rolling stone.

[agent99]

Basically you have to be a beatle or dylan to get 5 and it's rare people get 4, so three and a half is pretty good for them haha.

[headinaflurry]

For Rolling Stone, this is actually a REALLY good review. :) YAY! So proud.

But way to recommend a key track being a deluxe version track, lol.

[glass_houses]

Funny... my least favorite song :o

Mag, it's four stars. Our boy done good!

[ext_460807]

I love People Never Done a Good Thing but it kind of just seems like a remix of Greed (which is far superior) haha

[glass_houses]

Greed took a while to grab me but now I have to snarl loudly "POP YOUR WHITE COLLARS UP, POP YOUR WHITE COLLARS UP"