Comments | ice_whisper: What Almost Was

ice_whisper

What Almost Was

Apr 23, 2011 15:17

Title: What Almost Was
Character(s)/Pairing: Finn, Puck, Kurt, Mike, Matt, Artie, Finn/Puck friendship, and mentions of past Puck/Quinn
Rating: PG-13
Word Count: 2,617
Status: Complete
Notes/Warnings: A fill for this prompt by mayalioness. As for WARNINGS, look out for suicide themes.
Summary: It should make him feel better that Puck had written the letter ( Read more... )

character: kurt hummel, pairing: finn/puck, character: artie abrams, character: matt rutherford, character: finn hudson, character: noah "puck" puckerman, fandom: glee, character: mike chang

Comments 33

pairatime April 23 2011, 21:08:46 UTC

this...this was just beautiful just there is no other way to say it. It was dark and frightening and gut wrenching and hopeful all at the same time and if you were the one writing Glee I may still be watching. I just love this fic.

The letter was well written and spot on for that kind of note, the way Puck had though through his death, what stopped him and later had him try again on impulse was so on key. Finn’s reactions and that last line, it was just breath taking in it’s dark implications. So well done.

ice_whisper April 23 2011, 21:16:47 UTC

Thanks! =D

Aww. You stopped watching? =( The show hasn't been as good this season, though, so I get it.

pairatime April 23 2011, 21:31:14 UTC

I'm so glad your wrote it, I love your dark stuff it's so good

yeah, I loved season one but honestly I loved it for Finn and Will but I loved the rest of the cast too but season two Finn and Will just aren't the same and I don't like a single new cast member (Sam, Blain, Beast[she is the best of the lot]) and the focus on Kurt who I never really got into, he was okay last year but this season...I'm going to stop ranting now.

it was a great fic. so very great

ice_whisper April 23 2011, 21:40:04 UTC

Ahhh. I'm not a fan of Sam or Blaine either.

Glad you liked the fic!

Thread 6

klair716 April 23 2011, 22:18:53 UTC

Ugh... Wow. That last line is so heavy and beautiful. Great job ♥

ice_whisper April 23 2011, 22:21:17 UTC

Thanks!

Glad you liked!

david_of_oz April 24 2011, 01:34:15 UTC

Beautiful job.

ice_whisper April 24 2011, 04:03:29 UTC

Thanks!

ggbromance April 24 2011, 02:23:46 UTC

It seems as though every fic I read of your's leaves me in emotional upheaval. Oh well, that must just be a sign of greatness. This was emotional and crazy and so well-written and all that stuff. I'm not much for friendship stories but this one really got me. Awesome work :)

ice_whisper April 24 2011, 04:05:52 UTC

Thanks! I'm usually more for ship-fics than friendship myself, but I went into this not knowing if I was feeling a certain ship and decided to let the boys decide. Haha.

Glad you liked!

tigriswolf April 24 2011, 02:53:55 UTC

Oh, this is wonderful.

ice_whisper April 24 2011, 04:05:06 UTC

Thanks!