Leave a comment

Comments 6

naginis July 12 2012, 10:26:01 UTC
R01: CH04 VOTING
B e s t
#4, beautiful crop making me wonder what he's thinking about. And lovely mute coloring. :)
W o r s t
#3, it looks like the black part is taking over the image and the yellow is too strong. If the yellow on the right and the shadows on the left was toned down, I think it would work better.
#2, it looks too bright in the middle. Idk if it's a texture or what it is, but removing it or making the icon a bit darker I think could make the icon look better. Beautiful crop, though!

Reply


nalazhar July 12 2012, 11:10:18 UTC
R01: CH04 VOTING
B e s t
#4, great crop & coloring!
W o r s t
#1, while the coloring&cropping are lovely, it's a bit blury.
#5, the texture is overpowring the icon.
this was hard!

Reply


longerthanwedo July 12 2012, 15:49:19 UTC
R01: CH04 VOTING
B e s t
#5 - the texture use is wonderful, and I love the colors.
W o r s t
#3 - I feel like because the contrast is so high and the shadows are so dark that the icon is oversharpened in some places, mostly on Richard's eyebrow and hair.
#2 - I really like the crop, but I think her features could be brought out with some sharpening; right now my eye goes to her cheek because it's the brightest spot on the icon and everything else is so soft.

Reply


alexsuami July 12 2012, 19:30:11 UTC
R01: CH04 VOTING
B e s t
#04 amazing crop!! and i like the soft coloring
W o r s t
#03 maybe it's a little too dark on the left side
#02 i like the crop, but i have to choose!! maybe it's too bright

it was really really hard!! ):

Reply


latemorningicon July 12 2012, 23:01:02 UTC
R01: CH04 VOTING
B e s t
#01 - Nice coloring and shadow use C:
W o r s t
#03 - Icon is way too dark on the left side.
#05 - the texture use completely overtakes his face, making his features hard to make out.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up