Leave a comment

Comments 5

naginis July 3 2012, 17:42:17 UTC
R01: CH02 VOTING
B e s t
#1, lovely coloring
W o r s t
#3, the icon looks oversharpened.

Reply


blaanderstark July 3 2012, 23:32:55 UTC
R01: CH02 VOTING
B e s t
#1
W o r s t
#2

Reply


longerthanwedo July 4 2012, 00:27:54 UTC
R01: CH02 VOTING
B e s t
#3 - I love the colors and the light.
W o r s t
#4 - The image looks blurry and out of focus.

Reply


latemorningicon July 4 2012, 01:49:53 UTC
Wow, my icon's not half bad at all! C: *iz proud*

B e s t
#1. I really like the cropping of number one and how her face appears to be covered in shadows C:

W o r s t
#3. they're all really beautiful, but i guess i have to go with number 3. the blending is not as seemless as it could be (the edges around kate are a little rough) and the whole icon is a little oversharpened.

p.s. after the voting is done, would it be possible to find out who made icons number 1 & 4? i would love to ask them if i could snag or not C:

Reply


cb_janey July 4 2012, 04:47:10 UTC
R01: CH03 VOTING
B e s t
#4 - love the bright & vivid coloring + great contrast!
W o r s t
#1 - the coloring seems too dull as there is not enough contrast.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up