Comments | hymnia: Meta rec

hymnia

Meta rec

Jan 21, 2007 20:30

I thought this was an interesting topic of discussion:

fernwithy ponders what makes something "fandomable" or "ficcable".

After doing a couple of posts on things my f-list isn't especially into (Warriors and Tom Sawyer), I got to thinking about the question--what is it that makes something "fandomable" and something else just popular? (I'm not talking ( Read more... )

meta, furuba, fandom

Comments 5

(The comment has been removed)

nessabutterfly January 22 2007, 19:55:18 UTC

that list was just books--one of the other comments showed all of FFN and Sailor Moon is # 10

hymnia January 22 2007, 22:34:56 UTC

It looks like you didn't bother to scroll down and read my comment about anime/manga rankings before you commented. :P

SM ranks #10 overall, #7 for anime/manga, and #1 for shojo.

fiannan January 22 2007, 10:07:43 UTC

Interesting link, and a very cool discussion. Thanks for pointing this out :)

laurel_potter January 22 2007, 17:29:22 UTC

Many years ago I went looking for "Who's the Boss" fanfic on fanfiction.net, and there wasn't any. Since Tony and Angela took almost eight years just to say, "I love you" I was hoping someone would have written their wedding. Alas.

I actually wrote a fic of their first time, but I never finished it.

I need a "Who's the Boss" icon.

hymnia January 22 2007, 22:37:50 UTC

I know how you feel. I adored the TV show Life Goes On (and would still be happy to discuss it and read/write fic for it), but it has virtually no fandom. :(