This may be too cynical about Rose for you, but I've thought since I heard that it would be S2 Ten and Rose that it can't be completely straight. Because S2 Rose discovering a future version of the Doctor with a different companion would have had an emotional crisis that would have derailed the entire rest of her plot.
Meh, I think she'd have dealt. She had to know, on some level, that the Doctor would outlive her by centuries, and the thought that he was alone upset her at the end of "Doomsday". Getting smacked in the face by her own mortality (since she believed she'd stay with him as long as she lived) would have been fairly upsetting, of course, but she was never weak; any "emotional crisis" would have passed in the face of a real crisis.
However, I agree that a side adventure with a later Doctor and companion wouldn't have fit neatly into S2 anywhere, which is why I thought it might be a later Rose with Ten II when I heard Tennant and Piper would return. If this Rose turns out to be a projection of some sort, then, the only question is where Ten is in his timeline.
Comments 7
Reply
However, I agree that a side adventure with a later Doctor and companion wouldn't have fit neatly into S2 anywhere, which is why I thought it might be a later Rose with Ten II when I heard Tennant and Piper would return. If this Rose turns out to be a projection of some sort, then, the only question is where Ten is in his timeline.
Reply
Reply
Reply
I too thought this might be Bad Wolf Rose.
Reply
(The comment has been removed)
Reply
Leave a comment