Comments | hogwartslims: Voting - Round 01 Challenge 02

pierhias in hogwartslims

Voting - Round 01 Challenge 02

Feb 27, 2010 01:01

pickle_breath, foukay, ambersolace, katiegsr, henceforth, djmayhem_aubrey have been eliminated since they didn't enter and didn't have any skips left.
amorfati1013, munkymp3, untapdtreasure used a skip for this challenge.

Rules

Everyone can vote! You do not have to be a member of this community. However, anonymous votes will not be counted. Hogwartsishome members, please sign with name and house.
Participants are strongly encouraged to vote.
You ( Read more... )

round 01, challenge 02, voting, r01.c02

Comments 6

(The comment has been removed)

pierhias February 28 2010, 01:31:53 UTC

Please be careful about stating how much work or effort went into an entry. It's really hard to tell from the outside, and sometimes a lot of thought/effort go into subtle changes. I'll take that part out of your second least favourite vote, but the rest of what you have is good (though personally I'd love a bit more detail (: ).

anonymous February 27 2010, 01:44:28 UTC

pierhias February 28 2010, 01:33:59 UTC

Please check your first favourite vote. The reason you have doesn't match the number :)

anonymous February 28 2010, 01:35:56 UTC

pierhias February 28 2010, 01:38:11 UTC

Thank you!

Oh and one other thing, please be careful about stating how much work or effort went into an entry. It's really hard to tell from the outside, and sometimes a lot of thought/effort go into subtle changes. I'll take that part out of your first least favourite vote, the rest is fine :)

anonymous February 27 2010, 04:11:20 UTC

pierhias February 28 2010, 01:36:05 UTC

Aww, I'm sorry to hear that! Hopefully you'll be back full force for round 2, then :D

(The comment has been removed)

pierhias February 28 2010, 01:45:14 UTC

I promise I'm not trying to be difficult here, but I'll need you to change your second least favourite vote, please. There's nothing really constructive there, and the "tacked on" sounds a bit too harsh for my liking :)

I corrected the link to the voting guide up there, so if you aren't sure what works and what not, maybe check it out?

(The comment has been removed)

pierhias February 28 2010, 02:08:35 UTC

That's much better, thank you!

Generally what I'm trying to avoid is having wording in there that is unnecessarily harsh (which I know is hard considering that you're supposed to criticise). "Tacked on" - for me at least - implies a certain carelessness and indifference, which is probably not true since most icon makers care a lot about their work. If in doubt, be too nice rather than too direct and it'll work just fine.