Session Three, Round Four Results

[fatesong]

Time for the results of Round Four! Two people are being voted off, so that we will be left with 4 participants.

Comments

[quiddity_]

cool! i'd love a banner!
and comments would be fantastic for icon #4

[fatesong]

Comments for icon #4.

Least Favorite:
- The use of the textures can't be seen anywhere and it's kinda plain, with no much done to the pic itself. I like the placement of the tiny text, it suits the icon ^^

Favorite:
None.

I'm actually going to make all of the banners at the end, because it's easier for me to make them all at one time. I forgot to edit the post with that. xD

[quiddity_]

not a problem. ^^

[willowcanne]

Number 5 please

[fatesong]

Comments for icon #5.

Least Favorite:
- Similar reasons, the green and red background doesn't go with the green and red of HHR's clothes. And they're a bit too small for my taste, sorry.

Favorite:
- LOVE the coloring and texture to it.

Best Use of Texture:
- None.

[arishokku]

#3, please

[fatesong]

Comments for icon #3.

Least Favorite

- The cutting of hermione's hair. Is there something coming out of it? The icon looks cluttered. I'm not sure where the focus is.

- The black, white & green don't go well together, and it just looks cluttered.

Favorite

None.

[michygeary]

Oh man, I was so proud of my icon :( Can I see my comments, please? Number one.

[fatesong]

Comments for icon #1.

Least Favorite:
- Texture looks weird and Harry and Hermione have a weird coloring.

- Too blurry

- Harry & Hermione looked washed out. Oversharpened, but the 'main' picture could've been more defined.

Favorite:
None.

Best Use of Texture:
- The texture they used looks really good with the icon.