Comments | harthouse_cynic: Noooooo.

harthouse_cynic

Noooooo.

Apr 24, 2008 23:25

OKAY I AM DEVASTATED THAT CARLY'S GONE ( Read more... )

carly smithson, american idol, david cook

Comments 6

deppssexkitten April 24 2008, 16:11:14 UTC

MY JAW IS STILL DROPPED! Brook should have been the one voted off, FOR GOD SAKES SHE FORGOT THE WORDS TO THE SONG!!! plus her voice sounded really off in most parts of the song, or (i hate to say it cuz i do love him) but Jason Castro....his performance wasn't real good.

even though it was a given im still happy that DC is still in :)

harthouse_cynic April 25 2008, 15:51:09 UTC

Totally. Agree.

If Cookie leaves before he wins, I can't even imagine what I'd do. I'd NEVER recover, that's for sure!

bingomassacre April 24 2008, 17:50:07 UTC

carly totally did not deserve to go home last night. that was one of my favorite performances from her :/.

harthouse_cynic April 25 2008, 15:50:34 UTC

I liked the first half of her performance and cringed through the second half, but she totally didn't deserve to go!!! Brooke and Castro were WAY worse. A travesty!!!!

pearlescent_48 April 24 2008, 23:31:33 UTC

i was really shocked when i knew that Carly got out.
her 'Jesus Christ Superstar' performance was brilliant.

but i'm still happy that DC is still in <3
and i want David(square) to be in the final toooooo!!!! <3333

harthouse_cynic April 25 2008, 15:51:40 UTC

Haha yeah! David (Cook) must make the final if not the world is just a crappy place to be in!