Tainted Love - the Official Screwby Discussion Post

Mar 16, 2010 07:08

This is the episode discussion post for 1.03: Screwby ( Read more... )

!discussion, episode: screwby

Leave a comment

Comments 24

queeniegalore March 15 2010, 20:29:38 UTC

... )

Reply


charley_ryan March 15 2010, 20:50:40 UTC
I lay the most blame on shooting the kids on Trombley. Godfather did declare it a free fire zone but I imagine he assumed the men would know their targets were legit before firing on them. Which shows his disconnect with his men. Patterson knew it was a horrible idea to tell some of the men that. Godfather was clueless to the morons like Captain America and Encino Man ( ... )

Reply

queeniegalore March 16 2010, 09:40:14 UTC
That's my favourite quote EVER. I love it! The way he sort-of compliments Brad then looks over and says the rest all quick like he's saving face. Keep tugging those pigtails, Ray!

Tainted Love IS pretty special. I especially love Brad doing the handclaps. So much love!

As for Trombley, yeah, I tend to agree with you. Trombley needs to cop most of the blame.

Reply


emerald_skies March 15 2010, 21:20:37 UTC
I don't have any pics/gifs that I know are from Screwby, so I'll just post this one instead:


... )

Reply

queeniegalore March 16 2010, 09:43:55 UTC
Holy crikey, that gif. I love Nate BEST when he's being a stone-cold badass. So freaking hot.

free-fire zones are just asking for trouble, and command would've known that if so many of them hadn't been so disconnected from their troops.

I think that's a good point. Command seem to see the battlefield like a chessboard, without taking into account the individuals involved. The freefire zone looks like a good tactical move in that situation until you factor in young, sleep-deprived, inexperienced Marines - and young Marines like TROMBLEY in particular. He fucked up, simple as that, but he wouldn't have been able to make that fuck up without being enabled by command.

Reply


killer_fiend March 15 2010, 22:53:14 UTC
I think the blame can be laid on Trombley and on Godfather. First, God father for issuing the change in the ROE, and Trombley fro being a fucked up psycho and not knowing who/what he was shooting at ( ... )

Reply

michelleantonia March 16 2010, 09:03:03 UTC
LMAO you nailed some of the best ones right there!

Reply

queeniegalore March 16 2010, 09:51:07 UTC
I love that little speech of Walt's because it's like, the longest he speaks in the whole series, and I'm really fascinated by the wording and speech patterns. Because I am in love with him and a total dork, sigh. But the way he says 'boy' especially, just GETS me.

And this: PERSON - "Yeah, looks like Saddam's big bad Republican Guard Hajjis got wind I was coming. As the great warrior poet Ice Cube once said, 'If the day does not require an AK, it is good.'" Perfect Ray. Love it.

Reply


abrokencompass March 16 2010, 03:35:45 UTC
Hey there, coming in late but I just love discussing this episode ( ... )

Reply

michelleantonia March 16 2010, 09:09:56 UTC
Like Evan Wright, I actually really like Godfather, generally. In Screwby I tend to stay pissed at him the whole time, but he really was in a difficult position. Unlike those watching, he wasn't omniscent of what was going on in every team and company. He had to make hard and fast decisions on limited intel, and his mission was changed nearly daily.

ITA. he seems like more or less of a bastard depending on the specific situation, but if you look at his position and situation on a larger scale, you see that he's doing the best he can. and especially at the very end, that last conversation he has with Reporter.

Reply

queeniegalore March 16 2010, 10:07:42 UTC
Well put, bb. I hated this decision, but Godfather is, in most cases, a good commander. He got the job done, you know?

Reply

charley_ryan March 16 2010, 15:26:50 UTC
While Godfather can frustrate me, I also like him for the most part. I think he was being put in as difficult a position as his Marines were with the plan for this war. He made the speech in the 1st episode about how this was far from what Recon Marines are trained to do but he can't tell a general "I don't do windows".

Reply


Leave a comment

Up