The first story was a beautiful blending of worlds. Of Narnia, and Harry Potter, and the real world. I love the geneology and the family history and the magic and Luna looking for Narnia and Aslan.
And the novel written by "Uncle Clive" was just the perfect finishing touch.
I loved both crossovers, especially the first. As you might have garnered, I have a soft spot for Susan. It's so terribly easy to let go of the things that matter most. But I like thinking of her as Luna's grandmother, still with a connection to things that are magical; and I love the ending.
And Bellatrix/Spike *works* in a way that's perfectly unholy.
Susan's fate always bothered me. It never seemed quite fair that she didn't get a second chance; after all, Edmund and Eustace each got one after they screwed up.
I wanted her to be Luna's mother, but the timeline wouldn't fit--not with her being twelve or thirteen when the Blitz started. And since it was because of the Blitz that she and her siblings were staying with Professor Kirke in the first place, well...I had to put the relationship up a generational notch.
And I'm very, very glad that you feel that Bellatrix/Spike works. (I was having visions of horrible Sueosity.)
Well, the way I see it, Susan *did* have a second chance; after all, she was still alive at the end. The books, I think, reflect that it's often easier to redeem the spectacular sinner. The one who drifts away is much harder to catch. Lewis said in a letter that he believed Susan would eventually find her way back to Narnia, and I'm happy to believe that as well.
I suspect that no one who grew up speaking in an educated fashion could ever wholly alter his style or accent by speaking broad Cockney.
There may be a bit of Bella/Sirius subtext in the story as well. I think that Spike's workman's clothes, short hair and phony accent reminded Bellatrix of a certain cousin of hers who had rejected all things pureblood.
I really love the first one. It's so happy and sad at the same time, and the prose flows right along with the story. I like Susan having a second chance.
Comments 11
Reply
Reply
And the novel written by "Uncle Clive" was just the perfect finishing touch.
Reply
And I definitely need a Narnia icon.
Reply
And Bellatrix/Spike *works* in a way that's perfectly unholy.
Reply
I wanted her to be Luna's mother, but the timeline wouldn't fit--not with her being twelve or thirteen when the Blitz started. And since it was because of the Blitz that she and her siblings were staying with Professor Kirke in the first place, well...I had to put the relationship up a generational notch.
And I'm very, very glad that you feel that Bellatrix/Spike works. (I was having visions of horrible Sueosity.)
Reply
Reply
And yes. Bella/Spike works doens't it? Hee hee. And yes, that accent is terrible, Spike!
Reply
I suspect that no one who grew up speaking in an educated fashion could ever wholly alter his style or accent by speaking broad Cockney.
There may be a bit of Bella/Sirius subtext in the story as well. I think that Spike's workman's clothes, short hair and phony accent reminded Bellatrix of a certain cousin of hers who had rejected all things pureblood.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment