Round 1: Challenge 4 results
ELIMINATED:
nutmeg_05 (-6 votes)
irdamajere (-3 votes)
overevery (-3 votes)
PEOPLE'S CHOICE:
herm_weasley (+4 votes)
TALLIES: ( click here for your icon number)
1. -1 + 1 = 0
2. -3 + 2 = -1
3. -4 + 1 = -3
4. -0 + 4 = +4
5. -4 + 1 = -3
6. -7 + 1 = -6
I've put all the icon comments together this time so you don't have to search the positive and the favourites.
(-) = Lesser and (+) = Favourites.
ICON 01:
(+) Incredible coloring! great composition!
(-) standard coloring and a little bit too unoriginal.
ICON 02:
(+) pretty soft colouring and good text use
(+) The coloring and cropping is good and the font is very creative, the font placement is very good, too!
(-) A BIT BLURRY NOT BRIGHT ENOUGH NEEDS MORE COLORING TOO DARK TEXT IS TOO SMALL
(-) The text looks cramped, and the yellowish tint to her skin is unflattering.
ICON 03:
(+) Love the coloring and the crooping was great
(-) The exaggerated colour of her lips throws off the icon.
(-) her lips are too bright compared to the rest of the image and stand out, which is distracting and makes her look a bit like a clown
(-) The coloring is dull but her lips are too red, giving an unnatural. not very flattering.
(-) the color of her lips makes a strange effect with the color of her skin oO she looks too awkward
ICON 04:
(+) CENTERING AND TEXT LOOKS GREAT OVERALL COMPOSITION WORKS WELL
(+) great use of textures!
(+) the centering of the image and the tiny text works very well with the textures used here
(+) the icon looks dark but it's not unflattering and somehow this caught my attention.
ICON 05:
(+) love the use of coloring & texture(s)
(-) Too brightly and too blurry
(-) the icon is a bit too blurry
(-) The picture is overlightened.
(-) coloring is too pale
ICON 06:
(+) Great brush/texture work, even the crop is flawless.
(-) The swirl texture seems randomly chosen.
(-) GRAINY TINY TEXT LOOKS STRANGE
(-) the textures overpower the icon
(-) You can't see Jennifers face very well and the cropping on the face could be done better.
(-) bad us of textures
(-) it's too busy (especially the white circles distract), and the centered crop makes the icon rather unexciting
(-) it's too dark, the circles look pixelated and the pink texture is distracting.
I really, really need some help voting over at hilary_lims before I can post the results. It'll only take a few minutes and I'd really appreciate it. Thank you. ( Click here to vote)