Comments | ga_cast_lims: (без темы)

isolated_igloo_ in ga_cast_lims

(Untitled)

Aug 23, 2006 20:21

Sadly we have to say goodbye to these lovely icon makers:

twisted_badger

( Read more... )

chandra wilson, round 1, challenge 7, results

Comments 18

serenityone August 24 2006, 03:26:21 UTC

I thought for sure I was going to be out this round when I saw what everyone else submitted! Phew!

Can I get the comments on #11?

isolated_igloo_ August 24 2006, 03:37:09 UTC

- "not much has been done to the image and the font looks out of place. it is also slightly oversharpened or over contrasted"
- "The background is rather overwhelming her."

jaimekeane August 24 2006, 03:29:01 UTC

#2 Please

isolated_igloo_ August 24 2006, 03:38:43 UTC

You person who voted for you for people's choice didn't give a reason.

incripacu August 24 2006, 04:12:59 UTC

Comments on #01, please ;)

isolated_igloo_ August 24 2006, 04:18:57 UTC

- "Image is out of focus and washed out - the icon would stand out a bit more if the colors were less faded."
- "Nice use of colours and saturation"

snowdrop03 August 24 2006, 04:20:56 UTC

10 please :)

isolated_igloo_ August 24 2006, 04:25:21 UTC

- "It's a little too simple, looks like a straight crop/curves job without much effort."
- "It's nice and simple with pretty coloring."
- "I like the way is cropped and the coloring."
- "I like the gradient at the bottom with the white band. Very clean and simple."

Oops! You got 3 positive votes, not two negative and two negative. That was my mistake. You should be a people's choice also. I'll go make you a banner now! I'm so sorry about the mistake.

isolated_igloo_ August 24 2006, 04:25:41 UTC

I meant not two negative and two positive.

Fixed :) isolated_igloo_ August 24 2006, 04:37:05 UTC

I added your banner.

Thread 5

radon_ August 24 2006, 05:55:28 UTC

Thanks so much! Really thought I was gonna be out.

Um, #12 please? (:

isolated_igloo_ August 24 2006, 22:48:13 UTC

- "Blury"
- "The desaturation doesn't work well, especially on the background"
- "The lighting effect doesn't match the rest of the icon, particularly the blue background. The text is misplaced -- it overlaps with and is basically the same color as her hair. I also don't like the placement of the circle and how it cuts off the background image in half along the face."
- "Nice to look at. Really like the coloration and font of the text. Pretty good work."
- "looks very funky, the color changes work really well. Text placement could probably be a bit higher, but it still goes with the icon. Cropping is great. :)"
- "it's interesting and original"