Comments | ga_cast_lims: Challenge 4 results!

isolated_igloo_ in ga_cast_lims

Challenge 4 results!

Jul 21, 2006 20:25

Sadly we have to say goodbye to these lovely icon makers:

zoubidaa

( Read more... )

round 1, challenge 4, justin chambers, results

Comments 35

jaimekeane July 22 2006, 03:31:26 UTC

Number six please

isolated_igloo_ July 22 2006, 22:50:45 UTC

- "it feels like not much has been done to the icon. It's boring and it's a little too dark."
- "While I like the border and the little bit of light, it just seems a bit simple compared to others. Even just some text would've added a lot."

jaimekeane July 23 2006, 02:22:30 UTC

I love how simplicity is a bad thing.

isolated_igloo_ July 23 2006, 07:26:52 UTC

I would have to say that I don't think simplicity is a bad thing at all. A lot of the time I prefer simple icons to ones that are overdone. That's just my opinion though. It also depends on the icon.

Thread 7

thirteenthchime July 22 2006, 03:49:40 UTC

10, hee!

isolated_igloo_ July 22 2006, 22:52:14 UTC

- "nicely done!"

snowdrop03 July 22 2006, 03:55:52 UTC

17 :)

isolated_igloo_ July 22 2006, 22:52:56 UTC

- "I like the multiple images used where they are cropped differently, and nice coloring"

funsized July 22 2006, 04:43:58 UTC

isolated_igloo_ July 22 2006, 22:54:22 UTC

- "compared to all other too boring. And the coloration is a bit too much."

serenityone July 22 2006, 05:12:26 UTC

#5. Please and thank you :)

isolated_igloo_ July 22 2006, 22:55:45 UTC

- "oversharpened, texture over face, colour too intense"
- "The texture over the face makes the actor look bad."