{S2: Challenge 03} Results

[aztec]

★ Winners can request banners from custom_banners.
★ If you would like to know your voting results, comment with the number of your icon and whether you would like them screened or unscreened.
★ Submissions are now unscreened. Please get permission from the iconmaker if you want to use any of the icons from this round.

{ CHALLENGE 03 : RESULTS }
★

Comments

[aztec]

#1 (+2)
===========
[ + ] (no comment)
[ + ] The near-monochrome scheme adds to the feeling of cold, empty metal.
[ - ] It doesn't look like you have significantly changed this icon. It's only interesting because the original image is interesting. Next time, maybe try using more textures and/or light textures to really make the icon stand out.
[ + ] I really like the focus on the broken automail and the very simple texturing/lighting in this one. Very appealing.

[implication]

Wow thanks for PC!

Comments for #5 please, screened.

[aztec]

Please remember to include the # of your icon next time.

#2 (+5)
===========
[ + ] (no comment)
[ + ] I like the way the Philosopher's Stone is emphasized here, and the light effects make it stand out even more.
[ + ] Lovely contrast~
[ + ] I really like the colors of this icon. It has such a warm hue and the focus is really on the hand. The warm colors almost make it feel as if it once had life.
[ + ] The crop is plain, but the coloring more than makes up for it. Nice focus on the Stone.

[lalikaa]

Saw that one coming. xD

Comments for 6, please. Let's do screened.