Round 2 // Challenge 1 Results

Aug 26, 2010 18:02

Members' Choice and Mod's Choice winner banner maker for this challenge is tinini.

Challenge 1 Results )

round 2, results, challenge 1

Leave a comment

Comments 26

realproof August 26 2010, 09:42:46 UTC
aww, yay, thank you

loved your icon, isiscaughey!

comments for #20 please? unscreened is fine

Reply

shadowserenity August 26 2010, 09:47:56 UTC
See, I think you'll do really well this round :).

- [gorgeous coloring]
- The colouring is bright and clear, and the composition of the image (not 100x100) is a good way to approach this image.
- From the first sight icon look strange, but nice coloring attracts eyes and then you realize that may be she has golden wings? Little lady fair too? ;) Awesome effect, thank you!
- The image is far too small and the colour is too saturated.
- [i love the simple coloring, very vibrant]
- This is an amazing use of that cap. The lighting is wonderful, and the coloring isn't too orange.
- beautiful colouring; I also love how you decided to present the cap in less than 100x100; the use of light is lovely.

Reply

realproof August 26 2010, 09:57:44 UTC
naw, thx. I actually doubt it. I'll probably do sth really shitty for chall 4 or sth around that time, and then get voted off (with a reason, but still meh)

Reply


aryas_zehral August 26 2010, 11:54:47 UTC
Can I have my feedback for number 21 please?

Reply

shadowserenity August 26 2010, 12:11:19 UTC
- Image is blurry

Reply

aryas_zehral August 26 2010, 20:36:47 UTC
fair enough. thanks.

Reply


txduck August 26 2010, 13:09:31 UTC
Thanks for the mods choice :)
comments for #15... unscreened please

Reply

shadowserenity August 26 2010, 13:27:50 UTC
No problem :). I thought the B&W was really well-contrasted - and like your comments say, the icon looks like its out of an old movie.

- Lovely composition. Looks like scene from old b&w movie.
- Nice job removing his arm & hand; good contrast on the b/w

Reply


jehnt August 26 2010, 14:31:47 UTC
Comments for 24 please, unscreened.

Reply

shadowserenity August 26 2010, 14:42:20 UTC
- The character gets a little lost in the background. It would help if there was a change in color.
- Nice subtle coloring, and the icon is clean and smooth.

Reply


shadowserenity August 26 2010, 14:46:34 UTC
Just so everyone can see all the votes, I'll pop mine in here, too :).

#13:
- [gorgeous coloring]
- It's over-sharpened and the excess of vertical lines emphasizes the negative space.
- [wonderful use of blending and simple coloring!]
- Stunning contrast and coloring combined with fantastic texture use. I love the symmetry, offset by her asymmetrical hat.
- I like how she's anchored by the two dark lines and surrounded by light. Interesting composition.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up