Results - Challenge 02, Round 06

[dine7184]

Thanks for voting. Here are the results for challenge 02 of round 06.

Unfortunately we have to say goodbye to...

Comments

[bangel_4e]

Congrats to midsummerly!! And to everyone who passed!

My icon was number 8..I'd love to see some feedback and unscreened comment is fine :)

[dine7184]

+ Lovely crop & color
+ Love the crop and contrast in this!
+ Lovely, lively colouring.
+ i really like the crop

- Oversharpened on her collar and her hair. The crop is a little awkward where it cuts off her nose. Lovely colouring though!
- The crop seems to cut her chin off and it's also a bit too sharp for my taste.

[bangel_4e]

Thanks!

And this is great, I love feedback whether positive or negative :)

[vampire_sessah]

Congrats!
I love the icon of midsummerly so much! It's gorgeous :)

I'd love to have the feedback please and unscreened is fine :) I was #06

[dine7184]

+ the crop and coloring fit perfectly; the lighting gives the icon a great dreamy feeling
+ nice simple crop; good coloring and contrast

- I think the image confounds itself with the background, it doesn't really stand out.

[mark_pierre]

Comments for #1, unscreened is fine.

[dine7184]

- I think this icon could've been a lot better with some peculiar light or color change cause it doesn't stand out very much.
- Not enough contrast in the icon, which makes it look flat

[fan_cifully]

Congrats midsummerly! love the cropping :)
Could I have the comments for 7 please? unscreened is fine.

[dine7184]

+ lovely use of negative space & textures
+ beautiful soft coloring especially on the background

- actually, i like this icon, but still i have to choose. The coloring is a little bit dark
- Icon is dark and pixelated.

[blondeboy69]

Congrats to midsummerly, that was a beautiful icon <3

I would love to see the comments for #2, please - unscreened is fine as always :)

[dine7184]

+ Lovely crop & colouring
+ Beautiful crop
+ Great close up, and good job with detail and sharpness
+ amazing cropping
+ lovely crop; the monochromatic coloring fits perfectly

- I love the crop, but the colouring doesn't seem to suit it at all. This shade of yellow/greenish makes him look a little ill.
- the coloring is too green and doesn't really add to the icon