Comments | fringe_lims: Results - challenge 02, round 03

pierhias in fringe_lims

Results - challenge 02, round 03

Oct 12, 2009 14:52

Thanks for voting everyone! Here are the results for the 2nd challenge of round three.

( results for challenge 02 )

round 03, challenge 02, r.03 c.02, results

Comments 11

waterhart October 12 2009, 13:22:43 UTC

13 unscreened

pierhias October 12 2009, 13:48:31 UTC

- the icon looks over-sharpened and the text is hard to read
- Overall the icon is very sharp + the yellow colouring is unflattering on the white tones of the icon.
- the icon is overly sharpened and it has too much contrast.

adina_mpj October 12 2009, 13:29:08 UTC

can i have the comments for 07?

hallonpaj October 12 2009, 14:13:51 UTC

12 unscreened please :)

pierhias October 12 2009, 20:10:34 UTC

+ Great coloring

io_2 October 12 2009, 15:49:08 UTC

11 please? unscreened is fine. thanks!

pierhias October 12 2009, 20:12:37 UTC

+ The smudging effect is great.
+ Great composition and good b&w, though the central point could be a bit more sharpened

- too blurry
- Pic is too blurry
- The blurring around the characters is too distracting

dine7184 October 12 2009, 16:19:40 UTC

comments for #9, please. :) Unscreened is totally okay. *woot*

pierhias October 12 2009, 20:15:55 UTC

+ good position for the text
+ The coloring and the text is amazing.
+ Lovely colouring, and great texts and texture(?).
+ the colouring is pretty and the colouring and text works well