Comments | fionn_a_bhair: Deathly Hallows

fionn_a_bhair

Deathly Hallows

Jul 22, 2007 01:43

Having stalwartly resisted reading the 'Carpet Book' (if by resisted, one means seeing how difficult the images were and thinking 'fuck that noise') I got my greedy little hands on a copy of the new Harry Potter at 12.30 last night...

The Good

Molly Weasley does Ripley from Aliens. No words. Easily one of the best moments of the book for me.
( Read more... )

fandom, harry potter

Comments 3

gryffindor1475 July 23 2007, 03:15:35 UTC

Great icon! that was an awesome scene in the book!

I agree with most of your comments. But, I liked the scene between Dumbledore and Harry.

The Battle at Hogwarts rocked!

pokie4389 July 24 2007, 01:34:25 UTC

I agree with most everything you wrote! I was really disappointed in how little JKR used Ginny. Especially when she had all these things going for her.. being the only daughter, the seventh child, etc. I thought she might have done more than try to steal Gryffindor's sword.

And then Lily, she has ALWAYS been minimized! Remember in GOF when she comes out of Voldemort's wand all she says is "Your father's coming, he wants to talk to you" or some rubbish.

I also liked how much more real and frightening the blood prejudices were in this book. Some reviews I've read so far hated the "WW2" references but I feel as if those references are to be expected when your dealing with such outrageous prejudices.

I'm glad you'll continue writing stories in this fandom... some people are stopping for some reason that I can't fathom, haha.

hi siriusrocks18 July 24 2007, 05:52:17 UTC

hi! i'm here through jenadamson's journal. you don't know me but i've been following your stories (left behind and the best ship of all) and i think you've got a pretty solid grasp of HP characters - especially ginny, who is one of my three favorite characters (the other 2 being harry and sirius ( ... )