Who

Sep 17, 2011 20:17

Well, that was a surprise

SPOILERS!!! - and I mean it this time! )

doctor who

Leave a comment

Comments 15

lil_shepherd September 17 2011, 19:20:56 UTC
It was very much a thing of two parts. The overall themes are important to the series arc and characterisation, but the actual story was a bit lame and had no originality.

Reply

gonzo21 September 17 2011, 19:26:19 UTC
Lots of mirrors and reflections again, which seems the big theme of the season.

Reply

lil_shepherd September 17 2011, 19:37:57 UTC
I have maintained from the start that the major theme of this season is identity, while my friend parrot_knight has done some major meta on the themes of religion and faith. The evening's episode made contributions to both, but particularly to the latter.

Reply

ffutures September 17 2011, 22:24:11 UTC
Sounds about right.

Reply


paratti September 17 2011, 19:28:41 UTC
I really enjoyed it.

Reply

ffutures September 17 2011, 22:24:52 UTC
I didn't really warm to it much, for some reason, not sure why.

Reply


bellatemple September 18 2011, 03:42:39 UTC
This one for me was a bit of an Easter egg sort of episode. I'd have to watch it again, but there were definite bits and details added in that never get commented on that made it more interesting, beyond the fairly simplistic plot.

And yeah, I'm pretty sure that Amy and Rory are far too intertwined with the whole plot of the season not to make a comeback for the finale. (Besides, doesn't he, like, ditch them all the time? Every time Eleven comes back from a hiatus, they're sitting at home trying to track him down.)

Reply

ffutures September 18 2011, 08:59:50 UTC
Exactly - but doing it two episodes from the end of the series seems a bit silly.

Reply


willplant September 18 2011, 07:27:56 UTC
it reminded me a bit of a Sylvester McCoy / Sophie Aldred / Dr /Ace episode that i vaguely remember. it was about a 'vampire' that could be stopped by someone's unshakeable faith - and for plot purposes the doctor had to break Ace's faith in him in exactly the same way.

Reply

ffutures September 18 2011, 09:00:38 UTC
It's possible I'm remembering that (though I missed a lot of episodes in that period), which is why it isn't quite working for me.

Reply

willplant September 18 2011, 09:19:52 UTC
found it : http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Haemovore

from the Curse of Fenric

Reply

ffutures September 18 2011, 10:16:54 UTC
I remember them, though I'd forgotten the faith part.

Reply


maviscruet September 18 2011, 15:38:48 UTC
I loved it - a really messed up monster, a horrible threat, and a very dr who response.....

Reply

ffutures September 19 2011, 18:43:06 UTC
It just didn't click with me for some reason.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up