Comments | ff_party: Voting: Challenge 5

gabranth in ff_party

Voting: Challenge 5

Sep 27, 2008 23:27

VOTING IS CLOSED.

We have 29 icons to vote from this week. I'm really proud of you guys - you were able to get in about to submit almost 20 icons in one day, so that's way better than I thought it would be! :D Congratulations on avoiding the axe!

Rules ( Read more... )

round 1, challenge 5, voting

Comments 22

chibi_radish September 28 2008, 04:09:08 UTC

10: I really love the way you brought out the green in the outfit.

20: I really like the contrast of the size of the character and how the outfit just pop'd.

18: The out fit really stands out in a good way. The conntrast is great.

11: I just love it because it's so adorable! like how it's belt is binging. Everything mixs in well together.

swtxlove September 28 2008, 04:10:00 UTC

10 - Your icon has gorgeous coloring, it makes her outfit really standout from the background. It's not too oversharpened either. The little glowing dots add a nice touch to the background.
11 - The mask fits the fella just perfectly, great job! I like the usage of bringing out the yellows & reds in this icon, it makes the mask standout a lot more.
15 - Great composition & the use of tiny text. The only thing is the right & bottom grey strip, it seems a bit out of place. Maybe continuing the background would've been better.
20 - She makes a great little red riding hood! I love the colorful little textures & such in the background, it gives a childlike feature to your theme of little red riding hood.
28 - I think the whites should have been a little brighter on the outfits to make it standout more in the icon. Also, where'd Yuna's hand go? ^^; But the background textures & text are well done.

wounded_melody September 28 2008, 06:03:18 UTC

10: the icon is very beautiful, but I feel that it doesn't really stick to the theme of 'costume' (this also goes to a good number of other icons as well, I don't think of the outfits as costumes)
27: great pic choice, but I think it's a little dark
28: if I didn't know who they were I don't think I'd be able to tell

gunshou September 28 2008, 16:43:04 UTC

I thought the theme was to simply focus on a character's clothing, not necessarily put him or her in costume. I may be wrong, though.

wounded_melody September 28 2008, 19:47:45 UTC

I could be wrong ^_^; If so, just ignore my comment on that!

aesriella September 28 2008, 10:59:20 UTC

2- This is a nice, entertaining manip that's well executed (Grumpy!Squall at his best I must say) but the giant..disco ball?...in the background detracts from him and is very intrusive. Try a lighter background and maybe link it with Belle (see if you can find some little birds or whatever from the film?) to make a more cohesive icon ( ... )

deria_hime September 28 2008, 11:23:25 UTC

13 - The atmosphere is melancholic and the text underlines it quite well. I really love the coloring, it's dreamy, lovely and well balanced.

18 - Never saw a Stock used so lovely as in this icon. The picture of Aerith and this fall scence/colors really work together and the text is lovely, too.

23 - OMFG, hilarious! :D Thats a really nice manipulation though you could have worked more on the text. The colors look like his picture is drawn on an old parchment paper.

24 - HAHAHA :D Amazing! Absolutely nice outcome, though I would have worked a little more on the contrast of Squaller Pan.

28 - Really nice idea. I adore anyone who is able to use the Character/Sphere artwork as lovely as you did. The font as well as the text is absolutely awesome and the three really look like they're the fashion police.