Voting: Challenge 3

[gabranth]

VOTING IS CLOSED

We have 33 icons to vote from this week. Still not 100%. Starting next week, I will be implementing that -100 gil. Actually, the next challenge, the punishment will be even more severe due to the nature of the next challenge. But more on that in a few days

Comments

[senbonzakura77]

04 - I absolutely adore the choice of text!
06 - Lovely framing + image choice.
11 - Neat choice of cropping; very nicely done.
17 - Ooh, shiny - those lighting effects look so very ethereal! [which fits quite well with the character choice.]
18 - Nice cropping + blending with background.
21 - WHOA. That is a lot of resources, and yet they mix so very well together! Quite inventive.
23 - I really love the soft blending effects in this icon, and the light texture + tiny text make for nice additions.
33 - Wow, nice job on cropping & working that text into the icon!

[x_maps]

2 - This is such a spectacular icon, I love the use of contrast and textures to enhance a B&W icon. The hint of color in the background is lovely as well

[oulan]

12 - I love the coloring and text. It looks really soft and pretty.
17 - The crop/format is really great and I love the colors and use of textures.
21 - The look of it is really original. The textures and text work so well together.
28 - It's so simple but so emotional, too. I really like it. The tiny text works so perfectly.
32 - The colors are just stunning and the textures work with it so well.
33 - I love how great the image, background and text work together. The colors are really beautiful.

[missingfear]

06. The Framing is lovely; the cropping is excellent as well.
11. Unique cropping- the framimg is intresting, the lighting compliments, while the tiny text keeps it all in balance - good job!
17. Wonderful use of rescoures, the lighting, nature of the icon are breathtaking.
23. Your icon makes me feel intense. I love the lighting that you used also it give the icon a certian livelyness, Good Job.
31. I love how you used ligthing and texture to make the sunset stand out; it also highlights the theme extremly well.

[anniereckless]

06 - Great crop; the light texture (?) in the top right corner is a bit distracting though.
21 - Fantastic composition! Your use of textures and brushes is amazing here.
23 - Your coloring here is lovely; the combination of Tifa's torso and head on the left appears a bit awkward though.
24 - Great choice of screenshots; the brushwork/textures in the middle might have been a bit too much though.
27 - Gorgeous coloring and use of text.

[dark_sephy]

Where is the text is on #27> I can't see it no matter how hard i look *feels stupid*

[anniereckless]

Ah crap, I put the wrong number. x__x;
Thanks for the heads up ~

[anniereckless]

Ahhhh for 27 I meant 31! D: