Comments | felaine: ".......I'm Just Sayin' It"

felaine

".......I'm Just Sayin' It"

Jun 12, 2006 09:10

If I owned
POTC 2 & 3
The writers would be
G&G
Not T&T.

(geekmama and galadhir)

Felaine

Comments 16

hms_dauntless June 12 2006, 16:50:35 UTC

Yes. With them, James would still be James and Jack would still be Jack. And we would still have Lt Gillette, Anamaria, Murtogg and Mullroy... not just Elizabeth, Elizabeth, and still Elizabeth and Elizabeth.

(And let's hope Mr Rossio read this !)

txorakeriak June 13 2006, 18:46:20 UTC

James would still be James and Jack would still be Jack.
Oh! So there's proof of that now? O_O What did I miss?

hms_dauntless June 14 2006, 06:21:33 UTC

Well, I will attempt to give you an explanation without being too spoilering ( ... )

txorakeriak June 14 2006, 07:52:31 UTC

Ah. So no proof, actually. ;) That's what I was asking.
And nothing against your reasoning, but I just believe in audiovisual proof and I have no faith whatsoever in written stuff.

Thread 11

classics_lover June 12 2006, 17:04:36 UTC

Hear hear!

Well said.

ex_galadhir June 12 2006, 18:19:38 UTC

Oh wow! I'm beyond flattered! Thank you :)

I would have to make a special effort to put swordfights and explosions in, and some amusingly gruesome villains, and some jokes, oh, and Jack Sparrow, rather than just have the Naval characters talk at each other all the time as they tend to do in my stories at the moment though!

*Goes away squeeing* :)

(The comment has been removed)

ex_galadhir June 13 2006, 11:23:42 UTC

*Blush*. Thanks so much!

jacquesmoineau June 12 2006, 18:26:32 UTC

Why? :) Any more news on plotness?

sampaguita_blue June 13 2006, 05:29:12 UTC

Agreed.

(I'd change the producer too. Despite recent issues, I'd love to see a Speilberg-produced POTC.)