Answer: Should You Ever Use the Present Tense to Describe Someone Who Is Dead?

Dec 05, 2011 14:23


sosaith asks, "When someone is dead or something doesn't exist anymore, should you ever use the present tense to describe them?"

The answer is "it depends." Let's get down to the particulars with the cast of Rosemary Sutcliff's YA historical novel The Eagle of the Ninth - or, if you prefer, the cast of "The Eagle" (2011). ( Dead and/or gone - but not forgotten! )

grammar:esoteric rules, word choice:subtleties, pos:verbs:tense, !answer, author:chomiji

Leave a comment

Comments 4

sosaith December 5 2011, 23:21:17 UTC
Thanks for answering this for me!

Reply

chomiji January 14 2012, 02:47:49 UTC
I hope the answer helped!

Reply


pronker December 6 2011, 16:07:31 UTC
Neatly done; this post has so much subtlety in it! A melodramatic use would be if Character A did not know Character B is dead, and Other Characters allow Character A to persist in the belief and play along with the delusion for some reason.

Reply

chomiji January 14 2012, 02:49:18 UTC
Thanks for the kind words! Yes - it's really interesting how subtle differences like this can have a big effect on a passage.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up