Comments | eponine119: what the hell am I doing?

eponine119

what the hell am I doing?

Jul 26, 2005 00:05

Title: Stargazing
Summary: Neither of them had romantic prospects on the island; they had that in common.

( Hurley/Sawyer. You know you want it! )

[lost_fanfic]-slash, [lost_fanfic]-all

Comments 35

siren_mage July 26 2005, 07:32:44 UTC

Am I first?! Am I first?! lol, I've never been the first to comment on anything, so if I am that is some kind of exciting.

So, I was way wary of this fic, but decided to give it a chance. I'm really glad I did. Not quite my OTP, but not so bad either. The characterizations were nice and the whole thing flowed. I liked it. ^.^

eponine119 July 26 2005, 18:42:06 UTC

Thanks for giving it a try! I'd be wary, too...I was wary of writing it...but I'm glad you ended up liking it.

kho July 26 2005, 07:40:15 UTC

Aw, but. Hurley! No sad, Hurley! Awww.

Sorry, Hurley turns me into a mother hen. LOL.

And ya know what's strange? I totally bought this. I bought the kiss. I didn't think I'd be able to! I could actually see it. It seemed plausible. I gotta applaud you for that. LOL.

This was just great. Great great great. Great characterization, great Hurley angst, great Sawyer hidden pain. Great convo. Great all around.

Loved! THANKS!

kho July 26 2005, 07:42:07 UTC

I'm sorry, I need to clarify that. It's not strange that your writing was great, it's strange that my head could wrap around the concept of Hurley/Sawyer slash. Because that's a general squick for me. I don't know why. I loves the Hurley/Charlie. But. Hurley/Sawyer never crossed my mind as being plausible. I just meant that your writing superceeded my initial aversion to the pairing. So yeah. That's what I meant

eponine119 July 26 2005, 18:45:37 UTC

That's how I took it, from your initial comment, but thanks for the clarification. I'm glad you ended up liking it, and especially that you thought it was plausible. Since it is such a weird pairing.

ella_bee July 26 2005, 14:30:20 UTC

::blinkblink:: Hurley and Sawyer!?! ::eyepop::

And... you know? ...I think it worked.

Sawyer's characterization was awesome, especially how some of his throwaway lines really had so much meaning.

Hurley was good too -- his insecurities really played into this well.

Never going to be my OTP, but nice for a change. :)

eponine119 July 26 2005, 18:47:49 UTC

Thanks. I'm glad to hear you thought it worked. I don't think it's anybody's OTP -- it's not mine -- but it's fun to try different things sometimes.

dwlikeebeinlost July 26 2005, 14:44:24 UTC

AWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW

:::sniffle::::

Wuuuuuuuuunderbar!!!!!!!!!!!

eponine119 July 26 2005, 18:48:14 UTC

Thank you! :)

poisontaster July 26 2005, 17:46:06 UTC

This sounded like the most impossible pairing I'd ever heard of...but you made it work. My problem with a lot of slash is that its not plausible; it's just shove to pretty boys together and watch them go! This is plausible. More than that...it's heartbreaking. Great job!

eponine119 July 26 2005, 18:50:48 UTC

Thanks. I think it being such an impossible pairing is why I wanted to write it, to see if I could get it to work, so I'm happy that you thought it did.

I totally agree, about slash in general just being an excuse to put the pretty guys together. Which is fine with me, honestly, but what about the not as pretty guys? They should get a turn too.