Everything you said makes sense. I will bawl like a baby if he does die. BUT, that gives my other favorite Jeffrey Dean Morgan character some hope. Denny might actually survive if John dies. JDM has actually said that he likes playing Denny better than John. And I like Denny's character better than John, as weird as that sounds when I actually say it. lol Denny is more likable, yes?
But oy...four more days...then we find out...and then the long and painful wait....
I disagree, I disagree big time. The patient asked her to do the surgery. It's not for Addison or Alex to judge why, or to judge the husband, or the patient's marriage but as a doctor Addison has a responsibility to do what her patient wants. I'm not sure she should have said there was a complication, I would have said nothing and left it to the patient to explain in 4-5 years when the husband starts to wonder why she's not pregnant again.
The only fault I find is with Alex for being so judgemental. Who the hell is he that he can make judgements against anyone?
Let me rephrase, Addison shouldn't have done the surgery off the record. I think it's fine if she wants to do the surgery, I just don't think it should have been off the record and concealed as a complication.
Alex is such an ass.
I loved there at the end when Addison told him she was going to request him from now on, it was such a 'You play with fire, you're gonna get burned.' Addison is such a match for Karev. :)
You wrote exactly what I've been fearing for a while now...it makes sense narrative-wise for John to die, even if, as a die-hard Daddy Winchester fan, I tremble and wail at the mere thought *g*
One thing only I can say, that the writers have ways of writing John in the series but not in each episode..if the scope is to kill this demon (which I don't think they will do at the end of this season), the more teams at it the better, and John has demonstrated and said that he works better alone, while Sam and Dean are self-sufficient as a team. So, I do think John could survive and be written in a handful of episodes...I just wonder if the writers are willing to go that way or not.
That said...would you consider reposting your ideas in Papawinchester? Pretty please? :D
Heh, sorry. :( I don't want John to die either, but I think it's inevitable.
Yes, if the demon lives, I do think the writers could write John into a few more eps, and actually that would be better, because it would give them a chance to re-write his character to make him more functional for after the demon dies. It will be interesting to see what they do.
Comments 18
Everything you said makes sense. I will bawl like a baby if he does die. BUT, that gives my other favorite Jeffrey Dean Morgan character some hope. Denny might actually survive if John dies. JDM has actually said that he likes playing Denny better than John. And I like Denny's character better than John, as weird as that sounds when I actually say it. lol Denny is more likable, yes?
But oy...four more days...then we find out...and then the long and painful wait....
Thanks for your thoughts.
Reply
Reply
I love Denny. Denny is so sweet and adorable and I just want to snuggle him. I think Izzie would *die* if he died. *whimper sigh*
Reply
Reply
(The comment has been removed)
Reply
(The comment has been removed)
Reply
I disagree, I disagree big time. The patient asked her to do the surgery. It's not for Addison or Alex to judge why, or to judge the husband, or the patient's marriage but as a doctor Addison has a responsibility to do what her patient wants. I'm not sure she should have said there was a complication, I would have said nothing and left it to the patient to explain in 4-5 years when the husband starts to wonder why she's not pregnant again.
The only fault I find is with Alex for being so judgemental. Who the hell is he that he can make judgements against anyone?
Reply
Alex is such an ass.
I loved there at the end when Addison told him she was going to request him from now on, it was such a 'You play with fire, you're gonna get burned.' Addison is such a match for Karev. :)
Reply
You wrote exactly what I've been fearing for a while now...it makes sense narrative-wise for John to die, even if, as a die-hard Daddy Winchester fan, I tremble and wail at the mere thought *g*
One thing only I can say, that the writers have ways of writing John in the series but not in each episode..if the scope is to kill this demon (which I don't think they will do at the end of this season), the more teams at it the better, and John has demonstrated and said that he works better alone, while Sam and Dean are self-sufficient as a team. So, I do think John could survive and be written in a handful of episodes...I just wonder if the writers are willing to go that way or not.
That said...would you consider reposting your ideas in Papawinchester? Pretty please? :D
Reply
Yes, if the demon lives, I do think the writers could write John into a few more eps, and actually that would be better, because it would give them a chance to re-write his character to make him more functional for after the demon dies. It will be interesting to see what they do.
Sure I can re-post. :D
Thanks! :)
Reply
I'll try to come up with some counter-argument that works better than me whining 'don't want him to dieeeeeeeeee'
*g*
Reply
Reply
(The comment has been removed)
I love Denny, if Denny and John die it will just suck SO much.
It needs to be Thursday RIGHT NOW.
Reply
Leave a comment