My Immortal: Between Canons: Not Fade Away.

Oct 13, 2009 12:56

I bring you new fic! Specifically, the first of two STANDALONE ‘Fill-in-the-Blank’ stories (one short, one long) for My Immortal. The purpose of the stories is to tie together major events in the Who- and Buffy-verses, ironing out inconsistencies, and - as I said - you need no knowledge of (or interest in) 'My Immortal' to read them ( Read more... )

my fic, my immortal

Leave a comment

Comments 39

kerkevik October 15 2009, 09:21:41 UTC
Hi,

just read this and, despite not being a fan of either show, I was really impressed with the way you linked twoof the events I 'did' like about them, in a wonderfully believeable way; without losing the integrity of the originals, and gave Illyria the kind of Human face, which doesn't require her to become an imitation of Fred.

Really well done.

Still under Willow & Tara's spell,
Ray.

Reply

elisi October 15 2009, 10:08:40 UTC
Hello!

just read this and, despite not being a fan of either show
In which case I'm exceedingly grateful that you took a chance! :)

I was really impressed with the way you linked twoof the events I 'did' like about them, in a wonderfully believeable way; without losing the integrity of the originals
Goodness, thank you! One of my favourite things in the world is to get things to fit together, and make *more* sense. (Also known as fanwanking, of course. *g*) And I'm always thrilled when it works for others too!

and gave Illyria the kind of Human face, which doesn't require her to become an imitation of Fred.
I love writing Illyria because she's so very much Not Human, and yet at the same time she is influenced by people and events, and it changes her.

Thank you again for your lovely comment, and Willow and Tara's spell is indeed strong! :)

Reply

kerkevik October 15 2009, 10:28:22 UTC
You are very much welcome,

I took a chance because I have been an afficionado of your meta, the first of which, I think, was a few S4 thoughts. There I liked the even-handedness of your comments about Riley. I liked him, but he never worked for me, for me that whole arc buffy/riley/adam was the only real weakness about S4, which is my favourite, for obvious reasons :-), but also because it contains so many individually classic buffy stories.
I have to say that the biggest reason for me not being a fan of AtS, was it's lack of female-centredness, but also in the way they totally wasted a whole host of good Cordelia/CC plotline possibilities.
I love DB so much better, as well, now that he's allowed to show off his sense of humour.
As DW, it's ironic that I stopped watching the revamped show, just one story after, possibly one of the greatest DW story of all time, 'The Girl in the Fireplace'.

Still under Willow & Tara's spell,
Ray.

Reply

elisi October 15 2009, 12:40:31 UTC
I took a chance because I have been an afficionado of your meta, the first of which, I think, was a few S4 thoughts. There I liked the even-handedness of your comments about Riley.
Oh that makes me exceedingly happy! (A lot of my fic is meta in disguise btw. *g*) I'm very much anti-bashing, and like to look at things objectively, and - if at all possible - positively. Riley never did much for me, but he was a big part of Buffy's life, and as such deserved to be taken seriously.

or me that whole arc buffy/riley/adam was the only real weakness about S4, which is my favourite, for obvious reasons :-), but also because it contains so many individually classic buffy stories.
Oh I adore S4, even though the Initiative story was rather weak.

I have to say that the biggest reason for me not being a fan of AtS, was it's lack of female-centredness, but also in the way they totally wasted a whole host of good Cordelia/CC plotline possibilities.A lot of people feel the same way, I know, and killing off all the women (more or less) is certainly ( ... )

Reply


the_royal_anna October 15 2009, 17:19:50 UTC
Oh! I've been so intrigued about this and here it is, yay!

What a wonderful read, and an inspired idea! The descriptions here are just gorgeous, and you write a perfect Illyria.

Reply

elisi October 15 2009, 17:34:11 UTC
Oh! I've been so intrigued about this and here it is, yay!
:D I've been wanting to share for ages - and the next part is going rather well by now!

What a wonderful read, and an inspired idea!
*beams* I've been feeling very clever. *g*

The descriptions here are just gorgeous, and you write a perfect Illyria.
Thank you so much! And really, Illyria kinda writes herself... no one else is allowed!

Reply


juliet316 October 16 2009, 01:37:00 UTC
Wow. What a brilliant way to tie in the end of the Time War and the Time Locking of the war with the events of Not Fade Away and that climatic battle.

Wonderful way to use Illyria to great effect here.

Reply

elisi October 16 2009, 09:21:59 UTC
Wow. What a brilliant way to tie in the end of the Time War and the Time Locking of the war with the events of Not Fade Away and that climatic battle.
Thank you! :) Once I'd thought of it, it struck me as the most logical thing in the world, since the Time War must have impacted at a specific time.

Wonderful way to use Illyria to great effect here.
I think she might have used me! ;)

Reply


evilawyer October 16 2009, 04:45:02 UTC
Very nice blending of the two. And so right to focus on Illyria's character as the conduit to bring the two shows together.

Reply

elisi October 16 2009, 09:24:56 UTC
Very nice blending of the two.
Thank you!

And so right to focus on Illyria's character as the conduit to bring the two shows together.
It wouldn't work without her! Not only can she sense it, she can also absorb what it means, and be purely objective, not horrified.

Reply


moscow_watcher October 21 2009, 19:47:51 UTC
Gorgeous style and intriguing concept. As far as I understand, in your universe the battle in NFA happened at the same time as the last great Time War - right? (I wish I knew Whoverse better)...

Reply

elisi October 21 2009, 20:23:46 UTC
Gorgeous style and intriguing concept.
Thank you! :)

As far as I understand, in your universe the battle in NFA happened at the same time as the last great Time War - right?
More or less... The Time War(s) were fought out of time, but obviously the ending (the destruction of Gallifrey etc) and the consequences (the sealing of the walls between dimensions) must have impacted in 'real time', as it were, and what better time than the NFA battle?

Reply


Leave a comment

Up