commentary: when will i feel soft (tvd, jenna gen)

Feb 08, 2011 10:47

Commentary on when will I feel soft, as requested by leobrat. Can originally be found here.

Read more... )

fandom: the vampire diaries, commentary

Leave a comment

Comments 6

leobrat February 9 2011, 00:29:04 UTC
You really encapsulated EVERYTHING here. It was like...Jenna was born and then lived her entire life, and the show (and probably the books?) don't say even a quarter of any of this, but when I read this (the first time around), I was like, *yes*, exactly.

And I'm really sad that Logan got killed off so soon (I prefer Alaric and John in the shippy sense) but seriously, Jenna? Has SO much going on, with so many different dynamics with SO MANY DIFFERENT male characters that it just kills. KILLS. (Seriously, they can show Matt/Caroline/Tyler a lesson or two and that's saying something.)

And the family history with Jenna and Miranda...it just does fit. It just is the kind of history that would shape a woman the way Jenna is portrayed on the show, and shape her children, where we pick up where we meet them.

Thank you for this commentary so much!

Reply

empressearwig February 9 2011, 00:44:57 UTC
I don't think Jenna is in the books? It's a different aunt, and I think Jenna was created for the show. She's just a character that's obviously led such a full life and the show doesn't talk about it at all and it makes me sad.

(Like, there was a fic description the other day that said it was Jenna POV, Jenna/Alaric, Damon/Elena and said it was that way just so that there was another way to write their ship and it made me SO MAD. Jenna is not there for you to use like that.)

I am sad that they got rid of Logan. I appreciate that the show kills off characters that mean something, but at the same time I hate it, because now we don't get to play with his dynamic with Jenna anymore or Mason's or the three of them together. If they kill off John I will shank someone.

Thank you for asking for it! I had a lot of feelings about it, haha.

Reply

leobrat February 9 2011, 00:50:06 UTC
(Like, there was a fic description the other day that said it was Jenna POV, Jenna/Alaric, Damon/Elena and said it was that way just so that there was another way to write their ship and it made me SO MAD. Jenna is not there for you to use like that.)

Hmmm? Like...just there so Jenna could be the one narrating about how *great* Damon/Elena is? :/

Reply

empressearwig February 9 2011, 01:04:59 UTC
That was the impression I got. I didn't read it because I was too outraged, and I might have otherwise because no one writes about Jenna.

Reply


katayla February 9 2011, 04:26:36 UTC
I'm definitely glad you wrote this one! :D

It might have been mean, but I wanted to give her that moment of her life getting back on track before the rug was pulled out from under her again.

YES. That's a really great insight because, as little screentime as she gets, I think that's how I see her? Like, she really had started to figure things out and now she has to take care of these two teenagers and that kind of throws everything off.

Reply

empressearwig February 9 2011, 04:33:18 UTC
I am too! It's one of my favorites.

Yep. You get the idea that she had just started to figure out how to run her life, just her, and then there are these kids that she's suddenly responsible for and now she has to relearn her balance all over again.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up