Dub-con Dramione fics

May 20, 2012 10:18

*NOTE: This is not a recommend list, but a compilation list of all of the dub-con Dramione out there for the archives. I'll edit this list as fans make suggestions. Please try to include a URL, if you can.

According to Fanlore.com, Dub-con ('dubious consent') is defined as: "Dub-con" refers to sex involving dubious consent in fanworks. This ( Read more... )

specs: dark!draco, warnings: questionable consent, fic: recs (rating: nc-17), warnings: sexual content, warnings: mentions of rape, fic: recs (rating: r)

Leave a comment

Comments 27

anonymous May 21 2012, 14:05:51 UTC
Your list should correlate with the author's expressed warnings. If an author doesn't list dubious consent as a warning and only lists non-con, then I don't think anyone other than the author has the right to put it on a public dub-con list. Just because one person doesn't feel like the fic is "rapey" enough, or whatever that means, doesn't mean it isn't rape. Just because Draco is redeemable, or seemingly nicer than he could be in the situation doesn't mean it isn't rape. The entire dub-con label is problematic. It always comes across as "rape light" in fandom, perhaps to soothe the guilt of the author and reader who may enjoy it. But to each her own. The bottom line though is that it's really misleading to those who would use this list to put fics that are listed as non-con on the list.

There are at least 3 fics on your list that explicitly list a warning of non-con, NOT dub-con, they should be removed.

Reply

anonymous May 21 2012, 14:15:43 UTC
Sorry, to be more specific:

After Midnight by Gryffindorclutz
Bad to Worse by Kyra4
Sustenance by Softobsidian74
The Tast of Pain by xkissmewasabix

Reply

eevilalice May 21 2012, 15:11:51 UTC
It always comes across as "rape light" in fandom, perhaps to soothe the guilt of the author and reader who may enjoy it.

Shaming is never healthy or particularly healthy. I do not automatically read dubcon as "rape light," so please don't assume to speak for all of us, thanks, anon.

Reply

ldymusyc May 21 2012, 15:49:02 UTC
Yeeeeeeeeah, I'm none too keen on the implication that dubcon is used as a label to avoid admitting a work involves rape. I'm certainly not going to shy away from labeling rape as rape in my fics - see Quiritation, for one.

For me, dubcon involves situations of uncertainty. The primary question for me is "would this character say no under other circumstances?" Is she so drunk that her judgment is compromised? Is he under the influence of a potion or drug? Would she say yes if it was her choice, but someone's threatening her family/life/friends? Would he say no if he knew that he knew he was being filmed?

Like, if $CharacterA gets themselves so wasted after a night partying that they sleep with $CharacterB, who they might or might not fuck when sober? Dubcon. If $CharacterB gets slipped a roofie by $CharacterA, rape.

Reply


revolizandiditt May 26 2012, 21:25:40 UTC
I think you are doing a good job, so don't let some of these people get to you. Obviously, this is a touchy genre, but I'm surprised some people are getting so up in arms since they have been reading some of these fics for enjoyment/writing them!

Thank you for your hard work.

As for suggestions, I can help there. If anyone has a complaint about what I list as a suggestion, don't take it out on the OP, I'm simply giving suggestions and quoting the warnings the author has given.

Stone Dragons by gravidy : http://dmhgficexchange.livejournal.com/306299.html
The author has stated this fic to have "ambiguous consent". I have read this and find it to comply with what the author has stated.

Poison by Bunney @H&V. http://dramione.org/viewstory.php?sid=1010&chapter=1... )

Reply


anonymous September 3 2012, 17:08:40 UTC
Could you recommend a fic which has possesive/obsessed Draco
Similar to midnight/after midnight and at any cost.

Non con or dub con please!
I just love how possesive he is!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up