Comments | dh_oh_shit: Here's my theory!!!

wikkidgothbabe in dh_oh_shit

Here's my theory!!!

Jul 24, 2007 03:11

Severus is for all intents and purposes dead ( Read more... )

Comments 19

amsev July 24 2007, 07:40:32 UTC

LOL, that or absinthe! Or if I happen to find him on a beach, I'll offer to slathe him in 100 SPF sun-proof stuff. Must preserve that lovely paleness!

wikkidgothbabe July 25 2007, 04:58:17 UTC

Absithe is lovely too!!!!
i wonder if Severus has ever visited the *Green Faerie*!!!

anonymous July 24 2007, 08:06:56 UTC

That's a nice thought but not my understanding of how the resurrection stone works. I thought the point to the story of that Peverell brother was that you can never bring someone all the way back from the dead, only a shadow of their spirit.

The lack of both a body and a portrait give me hope for some cunning plan of Snape's, however he managed it.

windypoint July 24 2007, 08:38:12 UTC

My opinion is that if you used the resurrection stone on someone who was already a ghost, you wouldn't have that problem due to previous explanations of what ghosts are in the Potterverse.

wikkidgothbabe July 25 2007, 05:00:04 UTC

Yes, but as far as the story goes, Severus wasn't ever even a ghost... he could have been brought back.

wikkidgothbabe July 25 2007, 04:59:11 UTC

i don't really think Severus was ready to die.

yncarn8 July 24 2007, 08:10:15 UTC

Perhaps it was Hooch who was conspicuous by her absence.

She fell in love with Snapey in the first year and never got - Oh sorry JKR used that three times already. ;D

We certainly don't know what effect the stone would have on someone who is MOSTLY dead (as someone pointed out the other day) He has a body to go back to - Unlike the others brought back - asside from Remus and it could be argued he's a werewolf and his body is tainted.

loopyloonyluna July 24 2007, 13:36:57 UTC

I also get the feeling that Remus would not go back for love or money. Not even for his cute little rainbow pup who he's already insisted would be better off without him. Now Remus is with the men he truly loved instead of the wife he never seemed to have all that much interest in.

Severus, however, has nookie to be found.

yncarn8 July 24 2007, 13:42:53 UTC

And plenty of it if I have anything to say about it!

wikkidgothbabe July 25 2007, 05:36:32 UTC

My sentiments exactly!!!!
Bring it on!

Thread 9

rosedemon July 24 2007, 15:47:49 UTC

...or he is in Australia hanging with a aboriginal tribe or he is seen in Mexico City during the day of the dead festival, or he was seen in India walking the streets as a beggar, or he might just be in New Orleans working with the descendants of Marie Laveau on their greegree magic. Not sure on the spelling of that. :D

Any where but dead is what I hope for.

wikkidgothbabe July 25 2007, 05:02:57 UTC

It's gris-gris...
i hope for anywhere but dead also!!!!

hope_24 July 24 2007, 18:00:41 UTC

Yeah, the Resurrection Stone is totally just lying about in the forest. I like the idea of someone using it to bring him bak to life.

wikkidgothbabe July 25 2007, 05:03:53 UTC

Oh, i can only speculate... but i hope so too!!!!

Severus should NOT have to go out like THAT!!!!